Calculus3Sequences and Series4 of 6
Sequences and Series · 4

Direct and Limit Comparison Tests

1

Comparing with a geometric series

Let's find out whether ∑n=1∞12n+n\our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{2^n+n}} converges or diverges. Its terms approach 00, but that only means it might converge. It isn't geometric or a p-series, and for the integral test we'd need an antiderivative of 12x+x\our{\frac{1}{2^x + x}}, which we can't find. So we'll compare it with a series we already know.

Determine whether ∑n=1∞12n+n\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{2^n+n} converges or diverges
1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
2\htmlClass{lc-mute}{2}
3\htmlClass{lc-mute}{3}
4\htmlClass{lc-mute}{4}
5\htmlClass{lc-mute}{5}
6\htmlClass{lc-mute}{6}
7\htmlClass{lc-mute}{7}
nn
12n+n\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\dfrac{1}{2^n+n}}
Text solution
Compare with 12n\cmp{\frac{1}{2^n}}For large nn, 2n2^n is far bigger than nn, so the terms act like 12n\cmp{\frac{1}{2^n}}. Adding nn makes the denominator bigger, so each of our terms is smaller.
2n+n>2n  →  12n+n<12n\displaystyle {2^n + n > 2^n} \;\to\; {\our{\frac{1}{2^n+n}} < \cmp{\frac{1}{2^n}}}
The geometric series adds up to 1\lvl{1}Its ratio is 12\frac12.
12+14+18+⋯\displaystyle \cmp{\frac12+\frac14+\frac18+\cdots} =121−12\displaystyle = \frac{\frac12}{1-\frac12} =1\displaystyle = \lvl{1}
Our running total stays under 1\lvl{1}Every term is positive, so our running total only increases. It stays below the geometric running total, which never passes 1\lvl{1}, so it approaches a finite number and the series converges.
∑n=1∞12n+n<1\displaystyle \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{2^n+n}} < \lvl{1}

Here are the terms and the running totals side by side. Each of our terms sits inside the matching geometric term, and our running total stays under the geometric one, which never passes 1\lvl{1}.

1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
2\htmlClass{lc-mute}{2}
3\htmlClass{lc-mute}{3}
4\htmlClass{lc-mute}{4}
5\htmlClass{lc-mute}{5}
6\htmlClass{lc-mute}{6}
7\htmlClass{lc-mute}{7}
12\htmlClass{lc-mute}{\dfrac12}
nn
12n\htmlClass{lc-blue}{\dfrac{1}{2^n}}
12n+n\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\dfrac{1}{2^n+n}}
1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
2\htmlClass{lc-mute}{2}
3\htmlClass{lc-mute}{3}
4\htmlClass{lc-mute}{4}
5\htmlClass{lc-mute}{5}
6\htmlClass{lc-mute}{6}
7\htmlClass{lc-mute}{7}
1\htmlClass{lc-green}{1}
12\htmlClass{lc-mute}{\dfrac12}
nn
12+14+⋯\htmlClass{lc-blue}{\dfrac12+\dfrac14+\cdots}
13+16+⋯\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\dfrac13+\dfrac16+\cdots}
running total\text{running total}

The direct comparison test for convergence

If we have positive terms that are each smaller than the matching terms of a series that adds up to a finite number, our running total can never be greater than that number. So our series converges.

2

When an inequality starts later

Now a series we expect to diverge, ∑n=1∞ln⁡nn\our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{\ln n}{n}}. Once ln⁡n>1\ln n > 1, its terms are bigger than 1n\cmp{\frac1n}, and the harmonic series diverges. But at the start, ln⁡n\ln n is less than 11, so for the first couple of terms the inequality goes the wrong way.

1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
2\htmlClass{lc-mute}{2}
3\htmlClass{lc-mute}{3}
4\htmlClass{lc-mute}{4}
5\htmlClass{lc-mute}{5}
6\htmlClass{lc-mute}{6}
7\htmlClass{lc-mute}{7}
8\htmlClass{lc-mute}{8}
1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
nn
e\htmlClass{lc-mute}{e}
1n\htmlClass{lc-blue}{\dfrac{1}{n}}
ln⁡nn\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\dfrac{\ln n}{n}}
1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
2\htmlClass{lc-mute}{2}
3\htmlClass{lc-mute}{3}
4\htmlClass{lc-mute}{4}
5\htmlClass{lc-mute}{5}
6\htmlClass{lc-mute}{6}
7\htmlClass{lc-mute}{7}
8\htmlClass{lc-mute}{8}
1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
nn
ln⁡33+ln⁡44+⋯\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\dfrac{\ln 3}{3}+\dfrac{\ln 4}{4}+\cdots}
13+14+⋯\htmlClass{lc-blue}{\dfrac13+\dfrac14+\cdots}
running total from n=3\text{running total from } n = 3
Determine whether ∑n=1∞ln⁡nn\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{\ln n}{n} converges or diverges
1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
2\htmlClass{lc-mute}{2}
3\htmlClass{lc-mute}{3}
4\htmlClass{lc-mute}{4}
5\htmlClass{lc-mute}{5}
6\htmlClass{lc-mute}{6}
7\htmlClass{lc-mute}{7}
nn
ln⁡nn\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\dfrac{\ln n}{n}}
Text solution
Where the inequality startsAt n=1n = 1 and n=2n = 2, our terms are smaller than 1n\cmp{\frac1n}. But ln⁡3>1\ln 3 > 1, and ln⁡n\ln n keeps increasing.
ln⁡3≈1.10>1\displaystyle \ln 3 \approx 1.10 > 1
n≥3: ln⁡nn>1n\displaystyle {n \ge 3}:\ \our{\frac{\ln n}{n}} > \cmp{\frac1n}
From n=3n = 3 on, the sum goes to infinityThe harmonic series without its first two terms still diverges, and our terms are bigger than its terms.
ln⁡33+ln⁡44+ln⁡55+⋯\displaystyle \our{\frac{\ln 3}{3}+\frac{\ln 4}{4}+\frac{\ln 5}{5}+\cdots}
>  13+14+15+⋯  →  ∞\displaystyle >\; \cmp{\frac13+\frac14+\frac15+\cdots} {\;\to\; \infty}
Put the first two terms backThey add up to a finite number, and a finite number added to a total that goes to infinity still goes to infinity. So the series diverges.
0+ln⁡22+(ln⁡33+ln⁡44+⋯)  →  ∞\displaystyle \our{0+\frac{\ln 2}{2}}+\Big(\our{\frac{\ln 3}{3}+\frac{\ln 4}{4}+\cdots}\Big) \;\to\; \infty

Why the start doesn't matter

Even if the inequality only started at n=1000n = 1000, the first 999999 terms would still add up to one finite number. The same goes for proving convergence, so for both halves of the direct comparison test, the inequality only needs to hold from some nn on.

3

When a comparison proves nothing

If our terms are smaller than the terms of a convergent series, our series converges. And if our terms are bigger than the terms of a divergent series, our series diverges. But what happens if our terms are smaller than a divergent series, or bigger than a convergent series?

The comparisons that prove nothing
smaller than a series that converges→\toconverges
bigger than a series that diverges→\todiverges
smaller than a series that diverges→\to?
bigger than a series that converges→\to?

With terms smaller than those of the divergent harmonic series, one series converges and another diverges.

1n2\displaystyle \our{\frac{1}{n^2}} ≤1n\displaystyle \le \cmp{\frac1n}
∑n=1∞1n2 converges\displaystyle \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n^2}} \text{ converges}
12n<1n\displaystyle {\our{\frac{1}{2n}} < \cmp{\frac1n}}
∑n=1∞12n\displaystyle \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{2n}} =12∑n=1∞1n diverges\displaystyle = \frac12\cmp{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac1n} \text{ diverges}
1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
5\htmlClass{lc-mute}{5}
10\htmlClass{lc-mute}{10}
15\htmlClass{lc-mute}{15}
20\htmlClass{lc-mute}{20}
1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
2\htmlClass{lc-mute}{2}
3\htmlClass{lc-mute}{3}
nn
∑1n\htmlClass{lc-blue}{\sum \dfrac1n}
∑12n\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\sum \dfrac{1}{2n}}
∑1n2\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\sum \dfrac{1}{n^2}}
running total\text{running total}

With terms bigger than those of the convergent series ∑1n2\cmp{\sum \frac{1}{n^2}}, again one series converges and another diverges.

2n2\displaystyle \our{\frac{2}{n^2}} ≥1n2\displaystyle \ge \cmp{\frac1{n^2}}
∑n=1∞2n2 converges\displaystyle \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{2}{n^2}} \text{ converges}
1n\displaystyle \our{\frac{1}{n}} ≥1n2\displaystyle \ge \cmp{\frac1{n^2}}
∑n=1∞1n diverges\displaystyle \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n}} \text{ diverges}
1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
5\htmlClass{lc-mute}{5}
10\htmlClass{lc-mute}{10}
15\htmlClass{lc-mute}{15}
20\htmlClass{lc-mute}{20}
1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
2\htmlClass{lc-mute}{2}
3\htmlClass{lc-mute}{3}
nn
∑1n2\htmlClass{lc-blue}{\sum \dfrac{1}{n^2}}
∑1n\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\sum \dfrac1n}
∑2n2\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\sum \dfrac{2}{n^2}}
running total\text{running total}

So only two of the four comparisons give a verdict.

smaller than a series that converges→convergesbigger than a series that diverges→divergessmaller than a series that diverges→proves nothingbigger than a series that converges→proves nothing\displaystyle \begin{array}{lcl} \text{smaller than a series that converges} & \to & \text{converges} \\[4pt] \text{bigger than a series that diverges} & \to & \text{diverges} \\[16pt] \text{smaller than a series that diverges} & \to & \text{proves nothing} \\[4pt] \text{bigger than a series that converges} & \to & \text{proves nothing} \end{array}
smaller than a series that converges\displaystyle \text{smaller than a series that converges}
→  converges\displaystyle \to\; \text{converges}
bigger than a series that diverges\displaystyle \text{bigger than a series that diverges}
→  diverges\displaystyle \to\; \text{diverges}
smaller than a series that diverges\displaystyle \text{smaller than a series that diverges}
→  proves nothing\displaystyle \to\; \text{proves nothing}
bigger than a series that converges\displaystyle \text{bigger than a series that converges}
→  proves nothing\displaystyle \to\; \text{proves nothing}

That's why we guess the verdict first, from what the terms do when nn is large, and then look for the comparison that can prove it. For 12n+n\our{\frac{1}{2^n + n}}, we expected convergence, so we looked for a bigger convergent series.

Which comparison proves convergence or divergence?

4

Direct comparison with trig terms

Now let's try series with a trig function on top. The terms of ∑n=1∞sin⁡2nn2\our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{\fac{\sin^2 n}}{n^2}} go up and down, so they aren't decreasing, and we can't use the integral test.

1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
2\htmlClass{lc-mute}{2}
3\htmlClass{lc-mute}{3}
4\htmlClass{lc-mute}{4}
5\htmlClass{lc-mute}{5}
6\htmlClass{lc-mute}{6}
7\htmlClass{lc-mute}{7}
8\htmlClass{lc-mute}{8}
0.02\htmlClass{lc-mute}{0.02}
0.04\htmlClass{lc-mute}{0.04}
nn
0.71\htmlClass{lc-pink}{0.71}
0.21\htmlClass{lc-pink}{0.21}
0.002\htmlClass{lc-pink}{0.002}
0.036\htmlClass{lc-pink}{0.036}

But sin⁡2n\fac{\sin^2 n} stays between 00 and 11, and that's enough for a direct comparison. The same idea works on ∑n=1∞2+cos⁡nn\our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{\fac{2+\cos n}}{n}}.

Direct comparison on ∑n=1∞sin⁡2nn2\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{\sin^2 n}{n^2} and ∑n=1∞2+cos⁡nn\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{2+\cos n}{n}
∑n=1∞sin⁡2nn2\displaystyle \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{\fac{\sin^2 n}}{n^2}}
∑n=1∞2+cos⁡nn\displaystyle \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{\fac{2+\cos n}}{n}}
converges or diverges?\displaystyle \text{converges or diverges?}
Text solution
For sin⁡2n\fac{\sin^2 n}, use its largest valueThe terms behave like 1n2\cmp{\frac{1}{n^2}}, so we expect convergence and need our terms smaller than a convergent series. ∑1n2\cmp{\sum \frac{1}{n^2}} converges because p=2>1p = 2 > 1, so our series converges.
0≤sin⁡2n≤1\displaystyle {0 \le \fac{\sin^2 n} \le 1}
sin⁡2nn2≤1n2\displaystyle {\our{\frac{\fac{\sin^2 n}}{n^2}} \le \cmp{\frac{1}{n^2}}}
For 2+cos⁡n\fac{2+\cos n}, use its smallest valueThe terms behave like 1n\cmp{\frac1n}, so we expect divergence and need our terms bigger than a divergent series. The harmonic series diverges, so our series diverges.
1≤2+cos⁡n≤3\displaystyle {1 \le \fac{2+\cos n} \le 3}
2+cos⁡nn≥1n\displaystyle {\our{\frac{\fac{2+\cos n}}{n}} \ge \cmp{\frac1n}}
The other end proves nothingUsing 33 gives a true inequality, but ∑3n\cmp{\sum \frac3n} diverges, and being smaller than a divergent series proves nothing.
2+cos⁡nn\displaystyle \our{\frac{\fac{2+\cos n}}{n}} ≤3n\displaystyle \le \cmp{\frac3n}
5

When direct comparison points the wrong way

Earlier, ∑n=1∞12n+n\our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{2^n+n}} converged because its terms were smaller than 12n\cmp{\frac{1}{2^n}}. Change the plus sign to a minus, and the denominator gets smaller, so the terms are bigger than 12n\cmp{\frac{1}{2^n}}. And being bigger than a convergent series proves nothing.

2n−n<2n  →  12n−n>12n\displaystyle {2^n - n < 2^n} \;\to\; {\our{\frac{1}{2^n-n}} > \cmp{\frac{1}{2^n}}}

Still, for large nn, subtracting nn barely changes 2n2^n, so the terms should act like 12n\cmp{\frac{1}{2^n}}. To see how alike they are, we divide our term by the comparison term.

Determine whether ∑n=1∞12n−n\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{2^n-n} converges or diverges
1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
2\htmlClass{lc-mute}{2}
3\htmlClass{lc-mute}{3}
4\htmlClass{lc-mute}{4}
5\htmlClass{lc-mute}{5}
6\htmlClass{lc-mute}{6}
7\htmlClass{lc-mute}{7}
8\htmlClass{lc-mute}{8}
nn
12n−n\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\dfrac{1}{2^n-n}}
Text solution
Divide by the comparison termFor n=1,2,3,4,…n = 1, 2, 3, 4, \ldots the ratio is 2,2,1.6,1.33,…2, 2, 1.6, 1.33, \ldots, and it's never greater than 2\lvl{2}.
12n−n12n\displaystyle \frac{\our{\frac{1}{2^n-n}}}{\cmp{\frac{1}{2^n}}} =2n2n−n\displaystyle = \frac{2^n}{2^n-n} ≤2\displaystyle \le \lvl{2}
Compare with twice the geometric seriesMultiplying the bound by 12n\cmp{\frac{1}{2^n}} gives an inequality that points the right way. Doubling a convergent series doubles its total, so our series converges.
12n−n≤2⋅12n\displaystyle {\our{\frac{1}{2^n-n}} \le \cmp{2\cdot\frac{1}{2^n}}}
22+24+28+⋯\displaystyle \cmp{\frac22+\frac24+\frac28+\cdots} =2\displaystyle = \lvl{2}
Or take the limit of the ratioDivide the top and bottom by 2n2^n. Since 2n2^n grows faster than nn, n2n\frac{n}{2^n} approaches 00. The limit 1\lvl{1} is positive and ∑12n\cmp{\sum \frac{1}{2^n}} converges, so our series converges.
lim⁡n→∞2n2n−n\displaystyle \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{2^n}{2^n-n} =lim⁡n→∞11−n2n\displaystyle = \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{1}{1-\frac{n}{2^n}} =1\displaystyle = \lvl{1}

Plotted, the ratio settles toward 1\lvl{1} and stays between 12\lvl{\frac12} and 2\lvl{2}.

1\htmlClass{lc-mute}{1}
2\htmlClass{lc-mute}{2}
3\htmlClass{lc-mute}{3}
4\htmlClass{lc-mute}{4}
5\htmlClass{lc-mute}{5}
6\htmlClass{lc-mute}{6}
7\htmlClass{lc-mute}{7}
8\htmlClass{lc-mute}{8}
12\htmlClass{lc-green}{\dfrac12}
1\htmlClass{lc-green}{1}
2\htmlClass{lc-green}{2}
nn
2n2n−n\dfrac{2^n}{2^n-n}

We don't need a table to find a bound like 2\lvl{2}. Whenever the ratio approaches a positive limit, from some nn on it stays between half that limit and twice it. So our term sits between two multiples of the comparison term.

12⋅limit<our termcomparison term<2⋅limit(from some n on)\displaystyle {\lvl{\frac12\cdot\text{limit}} < \frac{\our{\text{our term}}}{\cmp{\text{comparison term}}} < \lvl{2\cdot\text{limit}}} \qquad (\text{from some } n \text{ on})
12⋅limit<our termcomparison term<2⋅limit  (from some n on)\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \lvl{\tfrac12\cdot\text{limit}} &< \frac{\our{\text{our term}}}{\cmp{\text{comparison term}}} \\ &< \lvl{2\cdot\text{limit}} \\[2pt] &\;(\text{from some } n \text{ on}) \end{aligned}
12⋅limit⋅comparison term<our term<2⋅limit⋅comparison term\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \lvl{\frac12\cdot\text{limit}}\cdot\cmp{\text{comparison term}} &< \our{\text{our term}} \\ &< \lvl{2\cdot\text{limit}}\cdot\cmp{\text{comparison term}} \end{aligned}
12⋅limit⋅comparison term<our term<2⋅limit⋅comparison term\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\lvl{\tfrac12\cdot\text{limit}}\cdot\cmp{\text{comparison term}} \\ &\quad < \our{\text{our term}} \\ &\quad < \lvl{2\cdot\text{limit}}\cdot\cmp{\text{comparison term}} \end{aligned}

If the comparison series converges, the upper bound shows ours converges too. If it diverges, the lower bound shows ours diverges. Underneath, limit comparison is just direct comparison with a multiple of the comparison series.

The limit comparison test

When two series have positive terms and the ratio of their terms approaches a positive number, both series converge or both diverge.

But when the ratio has no limit, direct comparison is still the way to go. For ∑sin⁡2nn2\our{\sum \frac{\fac{\sin^2 n}}{n^2}}, dividing by 1n2\cmp{\frac{1}{n^2}} leaves sin⁡2n\fac{\sin^2 n}, which oscillates and has no limit, so we used the bound sin⁡2n≤1\fac{\sin^2 n} \le 1 instead.

6

Choosing what to compare with

To use the limit comparison test, we need a series to compare with. Let's find one by looking at which terms grow fastest when nn is large.

Choose the comparison series for ∑n=1∞2n+1n3−n+1\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{2n+1}{n^3-n+1} and ∑n=1∞1n2+3n\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{\sqrt{n^2+3n}}
∑n=1∞2n+1n3−n+1\displaystyle \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{2n+1}{n^3-n+1}}
∑n=1∞1n2+3n\displaystyle \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{\sqrt{n^2+3n}}}
compare with ?\displaystyle \text{compare with } ?
Text solution
Keep the fastest-growing termsAt n=10n = 10, 2n+1=212n+1 = 21 is close to 2n=20\fast{2n} = \fast{20}, and n3−n+1=991n^3-n+1 = 991 is close to n3=1000\fast{n^3} = \fast{1000}. A constant factor doesn't change whether a series converges, so we drop the 22.
2n+1n3−n+1≈2nn3\displaystyle \our{\frac{\fast{2n}+1}{\fast{n^3}-n+1}} \approx \fast{\frac{2n}{n^3}} =2n2\displaystyle = \fast{\frac{2}{n^2}}
→  compare with 1n2\displaystyle \to\; \text{compare with } \cmp{\frac{1}{n^2}}
The limit of the ratio is 2\lvl{2}Dividing by 1n2\cmp{\frac{1}{n^2}} is multiplying by n2n^2. Then divide the top and bottom by n3n^3. Since 2>0\lvl{2} > 0 and ∑1n2\cmp{\sum \frac{1}{n^2}} converges, our series converges.
lim⁡n→∞2n+1n3−n+11n2\displaystyle \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{\our{\frac{2n+1}{n^3-n+1}}}{\cmp{\frac{1}{n^2}}} =lim⁡n→∞2n3+n2n3−n+1\displaystyle = \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{2n^3+n^2}{n^3-n+1}
=lim⁡n→∞2+1n1−1n2+1n3\displaystyle = \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{2+\frac1n}{1-\frac1{n^2}+\frac1{n^3}} =2\displaystyle = \lvl{2}
Under a square root, keep n2\fast{n^2}n2\fast{n^2} grows faster than 3n3n, so the bottom behaves like n2=n\fast{\sqrt{n^2}} = \fast{n}.
n2+3n≈n2\displaystyle \sqrt{\fast{n^2}+3n} \approx \fast{\sqrt{n^2}} =n\displaystyle = \fast{n}
→  compare with 1n\displaystyle \to\; \text{compare with } \cmp{\frac1n}
The limit of the ratio is 1\lvl{1}Divide the top and bottom by nn, which divides what's under the root by n2n^2. Since 1>0\lvl{1} > 0 and ∑1n\cmp{\sum \frac1n} diverges, our series diverges. Direct comparison couldn't settle this one, because our terms are smaller than 1n\cmp{\frac1n}, and that proves nothing.
lim⁡n→∞1n2+3n1n\displaystyle \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{\our{\frac{1}{\sqrt{n^2+3n}}}}{\cmp{\frac1n}} =lim⁡n→∞nn2+3n\displaystyle = \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{n}{\sqrt{n^2+3n}}
=lim⁡n→∞11+3n\displaystyle = \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+\frac3n}} =1\displaystyle = \lvl{1}

What happens if we pick the wrong power? Compared with 1n3\cmp{\frac{1}{n^3}} or 1n\cmp{\frac1n}, the ratio goes to ∞\infty or 00.

1n3:\displaystyle \cmp{\frac{1}{n^3}}:
2n+1n3−n+11n3\displaystyle \frac{\our{\frac{2n+1}{n^3-n+1}}}{\cmp{\frac{1}{n^3}}} =2n4+n3n3−n+1  →  ∞\displaystyle = \frac{2n^4+n^3}{n^3-n+1} {\;\to\; \infty}
1n:\displaystyle \cmp{\frac{1}{n}}:
2n+1n3−n+11n\displaystyle \frac{\our{\frac{2n+1}{n^3-n+1}}}{\cmp{\frac{1}{n}}} =2n2+nn3−n+1  →  0\displaystyle = \frac{2n^2+n}{n^3-n+1} {\;\to\; 0}

A limit of ∞\infty only tells us our terms are eventually bigger than those of the convergent ∑1n3\cmp{\sum \frac{1}{n^3}}, and a limit of 00 only tells us they're smaller than those of the divergent ∑1n\cmp{\sum \frac1n}. Neither proves anything, so we choose again by keeping the fastest-growing term on both the top and the bottom.

Which comparison makes the ratio of our term to the comparison term approach a positive finite number?

7

When the terms are a function of 1n\frac1n

In ∑n=1∞sin⁡1n\our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\sin\frac1n}, there are no powers of nn to pick out, because the 1n\cmp{\frac1n} sits inside the sine. So we look at the inside. If we write u=1n\cmp{u} = \cmp{\frac1n}, then u\cmp{u} approaches 00 as nn gets large, and near 00, sin⁡u\our{\sin u} is very close to u\cmp{u}.

uu
yy
y=u\htmlClass{lc-blue}{y = u}
y=sin⁡u\htmlClass{lc-pink}{y = \sin u}
11
12\dfrac12
13\dfrac13
14\dfrac14
usin⁡u10.840.50.480.330.330.250.25\begin{array}{cc} \htmlClass{lc-blue}{u}\quad & \quad\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\sin u} \\[2pt] \hline \htmlClass{lc-blue}{1}\quad & \quad\htmlClass{lc-pink}{0.84} \\ \htmlClass{lc-blue}{0.5}\quad & \quad\htmlClass{lc-pink}{0.48} \\ \htmlClass{lc-blue}{0.33}\quad & \quad\htmlClass{lc-pink}{0.33} \\ \htmlClass{lc-blue}{0.25}\quad & \quad\htmlClass{lc-pink}{0.25} \end{array}
Determine whether ∑n=1∞sin⁡1n\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\sin\frac1n converges or diverges
∑n=1∞sin⁡1n\displaystyle \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\sin\frac{1}{n}}
converges or diverges?\displaystyle \text{converges or diverges?}
Text solution
The terms are positiveSine is positive between 00 and π\pi, so every term is positive and we can use a comparison test.
0<1n\displaystyle 0 < \cmp{\frac1n} ≤1<π\displaystyle \le 1 < \pi
Compare with 1n\cmp{\frac1n}The limit comes from the Squeeze Theorem. Since 1>0\lvl{1} > 0 and the harmonic series diverges, ∑n=1∞sin⁡1n\our{\sum_{n=1}^\infty \sin\frac1n} diverges.
lim⁡n→∞sin⁡1n1n\displaystyle \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{\our{\sin\frac1n}}{\cmp{\frac1n}} =lim⁡u→0sin⁡uu\displaystyle = \lim_{u\to 0}\frac{\our{\sin u}}{\cmp{u}} =1\displaystyle = \lvl{1}

Summary

The direct comparison test
Smaller than a convergent series
12n+n<12n,\displaystyle {\our{\frac{1}{2^n+n}} < \cmp{\frac{1}{2^n}}},
∑n=1∞12n converges\displaystyle \cmp{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{2^n}} \text{ converges}
→  converges\displaystyle {\to\; \text{converges}}
Larger than a divergent series
ln⁡nn>1n  (n≥3),\displaystyle {\our{\frac{\ln n}{n}} > \cmp{\frac1n}} \ \ ({n \ge 3}),
∑n=1∞1n diverges\displaystyle \cmp{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac1n} \text{ diverges}
→  diverges\displaystyle {\to\; \text{diverges}}

When all terms are positive, being smaller than a convergent series keeps the sum finite, so our series converges. Being larger than a divergent series forces the sum to infinity, so our series diverges. The inequality only needs to hold from some nn on, because the early terms add up to a finite number. But being smaller than a divergent series, or larger than a convergent series, proves nothing.

Guessing the verdict first

Before picking an inequality, look at what the terms do when nn is large. If you expect the series to converge, look for a larger convergent series. If you expect it to diverge, look for a smaller divergent series.

Bounding a trig factor
To show convergence
0≤sin⁡2n≤1\displaystyle {0 \le \fac{\sin^2 n} \le 1}
→  sin⁡2nn2≤1n2\displaystyle \to\; {\our{\frac{\fac{\sin^2 n}}{n^2}} \le \cmp{\frac{1}{n^2}}}
To show divergence
1≤2+cos⁡n≤3\displaystyle {1 \le \fac{2+\cos n} \le 3}
→  2+cos⁡nn≥1n\displaystyle \to\; {\our{\frac{\fac{2+\cos n}}{n}} \ge \cmp{\frac1n}}

When a positive factor on top stays between two numbers, replace it with its largest value to show convergence, or its smallest value to show divergence. For divergence, that smallest value must be strictly greater than 00, like the 11 in 1≤2+cos⁡n1 \le \fac{2 + \cos n}. Because sin⁡2n≤1\fac{\sin^2 n} \le 1, replacing sin⁡2n\fac{\sin^2 n} with 11 gives a larger convergent series. Because 2+cos⁡n≥1\fac{2 + \cos n} \ge 1, replacing 2+cos⁡n\fac{2 + \cos n} with 11 gives a smaller divergent series.

The limit comparison test
lim⁡n→∞12n−n12n\displaystyle \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{\our{\frac{1}{2^n-n}}}{\cmp{\frac{1}{2^n}}} =1>0,∑n=1∞12n converges\displaystyle = \lvl{1} > 0, \quad \cmp{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{2^n}} \text{ converges}
→  ∑n=1∞12n−n converges\displaystyle \to\; \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{2^n-n}} \text{ converges}

When two series have positive terms and the ratio of their terms approaches a finite positive number, both series converge or both diverge. Use limit comparison when direct comparison gives an inequality pointing in the wrong direction, like 12n−n>12n\our{\frac{1}{2^n - n}} > \cmp{\frac{1}{2^n}}.

If the ratio has no limit, as with sin⁡2nn2\our{\frac{\fac{\sin^2 n}}{n^2}} divided by 1n2\cmp{\frac{1}{n^2}}, use direct comparison instead.

Choosing a comparison series
Rational expression
2n+1n3−n+1≈2nn3\displaystyle \our{\frac{\fast{2n}+1}{\fast{n^3}-n+1}} \approx \fast{\frac{2n}{n^3}} =2n2\displaystyle = \fast{\frac{2}{n^2}}
→  1n2\displaystyle \to\; \cmp{\frac{1}{n^2}}
Expression with a root
1n2+3n≈1n2\displaystyle \our{\frac{1}{\sqrt{\fast{n^2}+3n}}} \approx \frac{1}{\fast{\sqrt{n^2}}} =1n\displaystyle = \cmp{\frac1n}
Function of 1/n
sin⁡1n≈1n\displaystyle \our{\sin\frac1n} \approx \cmp{\frac1n}

For a fraction with powers of nn, divide the fastest-growing term on top by the fastest-growing term on the bottom, and drop any constant factors. Under a root, take the root of the fastest-growing term. If the limit of the ratio is 00 or ∞\infty, choose again.

When a term has 1n\cmp{\frac1n} inside a function, let u=1n\cmp{u} = \cmp{\frac1n} and compare with what the function is close to as u→0\cmp{u} \to 0. Because sin⁡uu\frac{\our{\sin u}}{\cmp{u}} approaches 1\lvl{1} as u→0\cmp{u} \to 0, compare sin⁡1n\our{\sin\frac1n} with 1n\cmp{\frac1n}.

Choosing between direct and limit comparison

First check whether the terms go to 00. If they don't, the series diverges by the nth term test. If they do, the nth term test gives no verdict, so use a comparison test.

Use direct comparison when a trig factor stays between two numbers, or when dropping terms gives an inequality that points in the direction you need. Use limit comparison for rational and root expressions, or whenever direct comparison points the wrong way.

8

Practice

1
Determine whether the series ∑n=1∞1n3+4\displaystyle\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n^3+4} converges or diverges.

When nn is large, what simpler term does 1n3+4\frac{1}{n^3+4} look like? Does that series converge or diverge?

Since n3+4>n3n^3 + 4 > n^3, which fraction is larger, 1n3+4\frac{1}{n^3+4} or 1n3\frac{1}{n^3}?

If you got diverges Being smaller than a divergent series like ∑1n\sum\frac1n proves nothing. To prove convergence, compare with a bigger series that converges.

Guess the verdictWhen nn is large, the 44 is tiny compared to n3n^3, so the terms behave like 1n3\cmp{\frac{1}{n^3}}, and that p-series converges.
1n3+4≈1n3\displaystyle \our{\frac{1}{n^3+4}} \approx \cmp{\frac{1}{n^3}}
Compare the termsAdding 44 makes the denominator larger, which makes the fraction smaller.
n3+4>n3\displaystyle {n^3+4 > n^3}
→  1n3+4<1n3\displaystyle \to\; {\our{\frac{1}{n^3+4}} < \cmp{\frac{1}{n^3}}}
Conclude by direct comparisonOur terms are positive and smaller than the terms of a convergent p-series, so the series converges.
∑n=1∞1n3 converges (p=3>1)\displaystyle \cmp{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n^3}} \text{ converges } (p = 3 > 1)
→  ∑n=1∞1n3+4 converges\displaystyle \to\; \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n^3+4}} \text{ converges}
2
Determine whether the series ∑n=1∞3+sin⁡nn\displaystyle\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{3+\sin n}{\sqrt n} converges or diverges.

The values of sin⁡n\sin n stay between −1-1 and 11. What bounds does that give for 3+sin⁡n3 + \sin n?

The terms behave like 1n\frac{1}{\sqrt n}, and that series diverges. Do we need our terms to be larger than a divergent series, or smaller?

Bound the numeratorBecause sin⁡n\fac{\sin n} stays between −1-1 and 11, adding 33 puts the numerator between 22 and 44.
−1≤sin⁡n≤1\displaystyle {-1 \le \fac{\sin n} \le 1}
→  2≤3+sin⁡n≤4\displaystyle \to\; {2 \le \fac{3+\sin n} \le 4}
Find a smaller divergent seriesTo show divergence, we need our terms to be larger than a divergent series, so we take the lower bound 22.
3+sin⁡nn\displaystyle \our{\frac{\fac{3+\sin n}}{\sqrt n}} ≥2n\displaystyle \ge \cmp{\frac{2}{\sqrt n}}
Conclude by direct comparisonThe series ∑2n\cmp{\sum \frac{2}{\sqrt n}} is a constant times a divergent pp-series, and our terms are larger, so our series diverges.
∑n=1∞2n\displaystyle \cmp{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{2}{\sqrt n}} =2∑n=1∞1n12 diverges (p=12≤1)\displaystyle = \cmp{2\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n^{\frac12}}} \text{ diverges } \big(p = \tfrac12 \le 1\big)
→  ∑n=1∞3+sin⁡nn diverges\displaystyle \to\; \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{\fac{3+\sin n}}{\sqrt n}} \text{ diverges}
3
Determine whether the series ∑n=2∞n2+5n3−2\displaystyle\sum_{n=2}^{\infty}\frac{n^2+5}{n^3-2} converges or diverges.

What are the fastest-growing terms in the numerator and denominator, and what does their ratio simplify to?

What is the limit of the ratio of n2+5n3−2\frac{n^2+5}{n^3-2} to 1n\frac1n as n→∞n \to \infty?

If you got converges Comparing with 1n3\frac{1}{n^3} gives a ratio that goes to ∞\infty, which proves nothing. The fastest-growing term on top is n2n^2, so the fraction behaves like n2n3=1n\frac{n^2}{n^3} = \frac1n.

Find the comparison seriesThe fastest-growing term on top is n2\fast{n^2} and on the bottom is n3\fast{n^3}, so the terms behave like 1n\cmp{\frac1n}.
n2+5n3−2≈n2n3\displaystyle \our{\frac{\fast{n^2}+5}{\fast{n^3}-2}} \approx \fast{\frac{n^2}{n^3}} =1n\displaystyle = \cmp{\frac1n}
Find the limit of the ratioDividing our terms by 1n\cmp{\frac1n} means multiplying by nn, and dividing the top and bottom by n3n^3 gives the limit.
lim⁡n→∞n2+5n3−21n\displaystyle \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{\our{\frac{n^2+5}{n^3-2}}}{\cmp{\frac1n}} =lim⁡n→∞n3+5nn3−2\displaystyle = \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{n^3+5n}{n^3-2} =lim⁡n→∞1+5n21−2n3\displaystyle = \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{1+\frac{5}{n^2}}{1-\frac{2}{n^3}} =1\displaystyle = \lvl{1}
Conclude by limit comparisonThe limit is a positive finite number, and ∑1n\cmp{\sum \frac1n} diverges, so our series diverges too.
1>0,∑n=2∞1n diverges\displaystyle \lvl{1} > 0, \quad \cmp{\sum_{n=2}^{\infty}\frac1n} \text{ diverges}
→  ∑n=2∞n2+5n3−2 diverges\displaystyle \to\; \our{\sum_{n=2}^{\infty}\frac{n^2+5}{n^3-2}} \text{ diverges}
4
Which of these series converge?
I. ∑n=1∞1n2+4\displaystyle\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n^2+4} II. ∑n=1∞n2n2+4\displaystyle\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{n^2}{n^2+4} III. ∑n=1∞1n+4\displaystyle\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{\sqrt{n+4}}

For series II, check the nth term test before trying a comparison. What is lim⁡n→∞n2n2+4\lim_{n\to\infty} \frac{n^2}{n^2+4}?

For series III, 1n+4\frac{1}{\sqrt{n+4}} looks like 1n\frac{1}{\sqrt{n}}. What is the value of pp for ∑1n\sum\frac{1}{\sqrt{n}}?

If you got (B) Check the value of pp for series III. The series ∑1n12\sum\frac{1}{n^{\frac12}} has p=12≤1p = \frac12 \le 1, so it diverges.

Test series IThe terms are smaller than 1n2\cmp{\frac{1}{n^2}}, so series I converges by direct comparison.
I:1n2+4<1n2,∑n=1∞1n2 converges\displaystyle \text{I:}\quad {\our{\frac{1}{n^2+4}} < \cmp{\frac{1}{n^2}}}, \quad \cmp{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n^2}} \text{ converges}
→  converges\displaystyle \to\; \text{converges}
Test series IIThe terms approach 11, not 00, so series II diverges immediately by the nnth term test.
II:lim⁡n→∞n2n2+4\displaystyle \text{II:}\quad \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{n^2}{n^2+4} =1≠0  →  diverges\displaystyle = 1 \ne 0 \;\to\; \text{diverges}
Test series IIIThe ratio to 1n\cmp{\frac{1}{\sqrt n}} approaches 1\lvl{1}, and ∑1n\cmp{\sum \frac{1}{\sqrt n}} is a divergent pp-series with p=12p = \frac12, so series III diverges.
III:lim⁡n→∞1n+41n\displaystyle \text{III:}\quad \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{\our{\frac{1}{\sqrt{n+4}}}}{\cmp{\frac{1}{\sqrt n}}} =lim⁡n→∞11+4n\displaystyle = \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+\frac4n}} =1,\displaystyle = \lvl{1},
∑n=1∞1n diverges (p=12)  →  diverges\displaystyle \cmp{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{\sqrt n}} \text{ diverges } \big(p = \tfrac12\big) \;\to\; \text{diverges}
Choose the answerOnly series I converges.
only I converges  →  (A)\displaystyle \text{only I converges} \;\to\; \text{(A)}
5
Determine whether the series ∑n=1∞2n+n3n−n\displaystyle\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{2^n+n}{3^n-n} converges or diverges.

Exponential terms grow much faster than powers of nn. When nn is large, what do 2n+n2^n + n and 3n−n3^n - n behave like?

In the ratio of our terms to (23)n(\frac23)^n, divide the top and bottom by 2n⋅3n2^n \cdot 3^n. What limit do you get?

Find the comparison seriesExponential terms grow much faster than powers of nn, so the terms behave like 2n3n=(23)n\fast{\frac{2^n}{3^n}} = \cmp{(\frac23)^n}.
2n+n3n−n≈2n3n\displaystyle \our{\frac{\fast{2^n}+n}{\fast{3^n}-n}} \approx \fast{\frac{2^n}{3^n}} =(23)n\displaystyle = \cmp{\Big(\frac23\Big)^n}
Find the limit of the ratioOur terms are greater than (23)n\cmp{\left(\frac23\right)^n}, but being bigger than a convergent geometric series proves nothing, so we use the limit comparison test. Dividing the terms by (23)n\cmp{\left(\frac23\right)^n} multiplies the top by 3n3^n and the bottom by 2n2^n. Dividing the numerator and denominator by 2n⋅3n2^n \cdot 3^n leaves 1+n2n1−n3n\frac{1 + \frac{n}{2^n}}{1 - \frac{n}{3^n}}, and since both n2n\frac{n}{2^n} and n3n\frac{n}{3^n} go to 00, the limit is 1\lvl{1}.
lim⁡n→∞2n+n3n−n(23)n\displaystyle \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{\our{\frac{2^n+n}{3^n-n}}}{\cmp{\left(\frac23\right)^n}} =lim⁡n→∞(2n+n) 3n(3n−n) 2n\displaystyle = \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{(2^n+n)\,3^n}{(3^n-n)\,2^n} =lim⁡n→∞1+n2n1−n3n\displaystyle = \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{1+\frac{n}{2^n}}{1-\frac{n}{3^n}} =1+01−0\displaystyle = \frac{1+0}{1-0} =1\displaystyle = \lvl{1}
Conclude by limit comparisonThe limit is 1\lvl{1}, and ∑(23)n\cmp{\sum \left(\frac23\right)^n} is a convergent geometric series with ratio 23\frac23, so our series converges.
1>0,∑n=1∞(23)n converges (ratio 23, −1<23<1)\displaystyle \lvl{1} > 0, \quad \cmp{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\Big(\frac23\Big)^n} \text{ converges } \big(\text{ratio } \tfrac23,\ -1 < \tfrac23 < 1\big)
→  ∑n=1∞2n+n3n−n converges\displaystyle \to\; \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{2^n+n}{3^n-n}} \text{ converges}
6
Determine whether the series ∑n=1∞(1−cos⁡1n)\displaystyle\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\Big(1-\cos\frac1n\Big) converges or diverges.

Let u=1nu = \frac1n. What do 1−cos⁡uu\frac{1-\cos u}{u} and 1−cos⁡uu2\frac{1-\cos u}{u^2} approach as u→0u \to 0?

Evaluating lim⁡u→01−cos⁡uu2\lim_{u\to 0}\frac{1-\cos u}{u^2} gives 00\frac00, so apply L'Hôpital's rule.

If you got diverges Comparing with 1n\frac1n gives a limit of 00, which proves nothing. The term 1−cos⁡u1 - \cos u is roughly u22\frac{u^2}{2}, not uu.

Check that the terms are positiveFor n≥1n \ge 1, 1n\cmp{\frac1n} is between 00 and 11, so cos⁡1n<1\cos\frac1n < 1 and every term is positive.
0<1n≤1\displaystyle {0 < \cmp{\frac1n} \le 1}
→  cos⁡1n<1  →  1−cos⁡1n>0\displaystyle \to\; \cos\frac1n < 1 \;\to\; \our{1-\cos\frac1n} > 0
Compare with 1n2\cmp{\frac{1}{n^2}}Let u=1n\cmp{u} = \cmp{\frac1n}, which approaches 00. The ratio gives 00\frac00, so we apply L'Hôpital's rule twice.
u\displaystyle \cmp{u} =1n:lim⁡n→∞1−cos⁡1n1n2\displaystyle = \cmp{\frac1n}: \quad \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{\our{1-\cos\frac1n}}{\cmp{\frac{1}{n^2}}} =lim⁡u→01−cos⁡uu2\displaystyle = \lim_{u\to0}\frac{\our{1-\cos u}}{\cmp{u^2}} =lim⁡u→0sin⁡u2u\displaystyle = \lim_{u\to0}\frac{\sin u}{2u} =lim⁡u→0cos⁡u2\displaystyle = \lim_{u\to0}\frac{\cos u}{2} =12\displaystyle = \lvl{\frac12}
Conclude by limit comparisonThe limit is positive and finite, and ∑1n2\cmp{\sum \frac{1}{n^2}} converges, so our series converges.
12>0,∑n=1∞1n2 converges\displaystyle \lvl{\frac12} > 0, \quad \cmp{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n^2}} \text{ converges}
→  ∑n=1∞(1−cos⁡1n) converges\displaystyle \to\; \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\Big(1-\cos\frac1n\Big)} \text{ converges}
7
Determine whether the series ∑n=1∞1n1+1n\displaystyle\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n^{1+\frac1n}} converges or diverges. (Challenge)

Divide 1n1+1n\frac{1}{n^{1+\frac1n}} by 1n\frac1n. What does the ratio simplify to?

Write n1nn^{\frac1n} as eln⁡nne^{\frac{\ln n}{n}}. What is the limit of ln⁡nn\frac{\ln n}{n} as n→∞n \to \infty?

If you got converges The p-series test requires a fixed power pp. Here the exponent 1+1n1 + \frac1n changes with nn and approaches 11.

Set up the ratio with 1n\cmp{\frac1n}The exponent 1+1n1 + \frac1n approaches 11 as n→∞n \to \infty, so we test limit comparison with 1n\cmp{\frac1n}. Factoring n1+1nn^{1 + \frac1n} as n⋅n1nn \cdot n^{\frac1n} lets the factor of nn cancel when we divide by 1n\cmp{\frac1n}.
1n1+1n1n\displaystyle \frac{\our{\frac{1}{n^{1+\frac1n}}}}{\cmp{\frac1n}} =nn⋅n1n\displaystyle = \frac{n}{n\cdot n^{\frac1n}} =1n1n\displaystyle = \frac{1}{n^{\frac1n}}
Find the limit of n1nn^{\frac1n}Write n1nn^{\frac1n} in exponential form, then use L'Hôpital's rule to show that ln⁡nn→0\frac{\ln n}{n} \to 0.
n1n\displaystyle n^{\frac1n} =eln⁡nn,lim⁡n→∞ln⁡nn\displaystyle = e^{\frac{\ln n}{n}}, \qquad \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{\ln n}{n} =lim⁡n→∞1n1\displaystyle = \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{\frac1n}{1} =0  →  lim⁡n→∞n1n\displaystyle = 0 \;\to\; \lim_{n\to\infty} n^{\frac1n} =e0\displaystyle = e^0 =1\displaystyle = 1
Conclude by limit comparisonThe ratio approaches 1\lvl{1}, and the harmonic series ∑1n\cmp{\sum \frac1n} diverges, so our series diverges.
lim⁡n→∞1n1n\displaystyle \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{1}{n^{\frac1n}} =1>0,∑n=1∞1n diverges\displaystyle = \lvl{1} > 0, \quad \cmp{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac1n} \text{ diverges}
→  ∑n=1∞1n1+1n diverges\displaystyle \to\; \our{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n^{1+\frac1n}}} \text{ diverges}