Calculus3Limits and Continuity8 of 8
Limits and Continuity · 8

Epsilon-Delta Definition of a Limit

1

What "close enough" means in numbers

We know that lim⁡x→2(2x+1)=5\lim_{x\to \dl{2}}(2x + 1) = \ep{5}. We usually say that we can make f(x)=2x+1f(x) = 2x + 1 as close to 5\ep{5} as we want, as long as xx is close enough to 2\dl{2}, without letting x=2\dl{x = 2}. Checking x=1.9x = 1.9, 1.991.99 and 1.9991.999 gives f(x)=4.8f(x) = 4.8, 4.984.98 and 4.9984.998, but three numbers don't tell us about every xx near 2\dl{2}. To write a rule that does, we turn "as close as we want" and "close enough" into distances.

What "close enough" means for y=2x+1y = 2x + 1 near (2,5)(2, 5)
xx
yy
y=2x+1y = 2x + 1
4\htmlClass{lc-pink}{4}
5\htmlClass{lc-pink}{5}
6\htmlClass{lc-pink}{6}
ε=1\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\varepsilon = 1}
2\htmlClass{lc-blue}{2}
Text solution
Write each distance as an absolute valueThe distance from xx to 2\dl{2} is ∣x−2∣\dl{|x - 2|}, and the distance from f(x)f(x) to 5\ep{5} is ∣f(x)−5∣\ep{|f(x) - 5|}.
∣x−2∣<0.5  ⟺  1.5<x<2.5\displaystyle \dl{|x - 2| < 0.5} \iff \dl{1.5 < x < 2.5}
∣f(x)−5∣<1  ⟺  4<f(x)<6\displaystyle \ep{|f(x) - 5| < 1} \iff \ep{4 < f(x) < 6}
A smaller ε\ep{\varepsilon} needs a new δ\dl{\delta}For ε=0.1\ep{\varepsilon = 0.1}, the old δ=0.5\dl{\delta = 0.5} lets in x=2.4\dl{x = 2.4}, whose output is too far from 5\ep{5}. Solving again gives δ=0.05\dl{\delta = 0.05}.
ε=0.1, δ=0.5:x=2.4,  f(2.4)=5.8>5.1\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\ep{\varepsilon = 0.1},\ \dl{\delta = 0.5}: \quad \dl{x = 2.4},\ \ f(\dl{2.4}) = \outs{5.8} > \ep{5.1}\end{aligned}
ε=0.1:4.9<2x+1<5.1  ⇒  1.95<x<2.05  ⇒  δ=0.05\displaystyle \ep{\varepsilon = 0.1}: \quad \ep{4.9 < 2x + 1 < 5.1} \;\Rightarrow\; \dl{1.95 < x < 2.05} \;\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta = 0.05}
ε=0.1, δ=0.5:x=2.4,  f(2.4)=5.8>5.1\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\ep{\varepsilon = 0.1},\ \dl{\delta = 0.5}: \\ &\dl{x = 2.4},\ \ f(\dl{2.4}) = \outs{5.8} > \ep{5.1} \end{aligned}
ε=0.1:  4.9<2x+1<5.1⇒  1.95<x<2.05⇒  δ=0.05\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\ep{\varepsilon = 0.1}: \ \ \ep{4.9 < 2x + 1 < 5.1} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \dl{1.95 < x < 2.05} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta = 0.05} \end{aligned}
One rule for every ε\ep{\varepsilon}The slope of y=2x+1y = 2x + 1 is 2\fc{2}, so yy changes twice as fast as xx. To keep f(x)f(x) within ε\ep{\varepsilon} of 5\ep{5}, xx has to stay within ε2\frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}} of 2\dl{2}.
δ\displaystyle \dl{\delta} =ε2\displaystyle = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}}

Here's the picture for ε=1\ep{\varepsilon = 1}. The outputs from 4\ep{4} to 6\ep{6} carry across to the line and down to the inputs from 1.5\dl{1.5} to 2.5\dl{2.5}, which are 0.5\dl{0.5} from 2\dl{2} on each side.

xx
yy
y=2x+1y = 2x + 1
4\htmlClass{lc-pink}{4}
5\htmlClass{lc-pink}{5}
6\htmlClass{lc-pink}{6}
ε=1\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\varepsilon = 1}
1.5\htmlClass{lc-blue}{1.5}
2\htmlClass{lc-blue}{2}
2.5\htmlClass{lc-blue}{2.5}
δ=0.5\htmlClass{lc-blue}{\delta = 0.5}
ε=1:  4<2x+1<6⇒  1.5<x<2.5⇒  δ=0.5\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\ep{\varepsilon = 1}: \ \ \ep{4 < 2x + 1 < 6} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \dl{1.5 < x < 2.5} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta = 0.5} \end{aligned}

Replacing 2\dl{2} with a\dl{a} and 5\ep{5} with L\ep{L} gives the precise definition of a limit. For every ε>0\ep{\varepsilon > 0}, there is a δ>0\dl{\delta > 0} such that all xx within δ\dl{\delta} of a\dl{a}, except a\dl{a} itself, have f(x)f(x) within ε\ep{\varepsilon} of L\ep{L}.

lim⁡x→af(x)\displaystyle \lim_{x\to \dl{a}} f(x) =L:\displaystyle = \ep{L}:
for every ε>0 there is a δ>0 such that\displaystyle \text{for every } \ep{\varepsilon > 0} \text{ there is a } \dl{\delta > 0} \text{ such that}
for every ε>0\displaystyle \text{for every } \ep{\varepsilon > 0}
there is a δ>0 such that\displaystyle \text{there is a } \dl{\delta > 0} \text{ such that}
0<∣x−a∣<δ  ⇒  ∣f(x)−L∣<ε\htmlClass{lc-blue}{0 < |x - a| < \delta} \;\Rightarrow\; \htmlClass{lc-pink}{|f(x) - L| < \varepsilon}
the inputs\htmlClass{lc-blue}{\text{the inputs}}
within δ of a\htmlClass{lc-blue}{\text{within } \delta \text{ of } a}
the outputs\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\text{the outputs}}
within ε of L\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\text{within } \varepsilon \text{ of } L}
x≠a\htmlClass{lc-blue}{x \ne a}
a=2, L=5:0<∣x−2∣<δ  ⇒  ∣(2x+1)−5∣<ε,δ=ε2\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\dl{a = 2},\ \ep{L = 5}: \quad \dl{0 < |x - 2| < \delta} \;\Rightarrow\; \ep{|(2x + 1) - 5| < \varepsilon}, \qquad \dl{\delta} = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}}\end{aligned}
a=2, L=5:0<∣x−2∣<δ⇒  ∣(2x+1)−5∣<εδ=ε2\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\dl{a = 2},\ \ep{L = 5}: \\ &\dl{0 < |x - 2| < \delta} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \ep{|(2x + 1) - 5| < \varepsilon} \\ &\dl{\delta} = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}} \end{aligned}

A limit never depends on the value at a\dl{a} itself, so we write 0<∣x−a∣\dl{0 < |x - a|} to say that x≠a\dl{x \ne a}.

2

When the two sides give different distances

On a curve, finding δ\dl{\delta} has a catch. Take lim⁡x→9x=3\lim_{x\to \dl{9}}\sqrt{x} = \ep{3} with ε=1\ep{\varepsilon = 1}, so x\sqrt{x} has to stay between 2\ep{2} and 4\ep{4}. Carrying y=2\ep{y = 2} and y=4\ep{y = 4} across to the curve and down to the x-axis lands at x=4\dl{x = 4} and x=16\dl{x = 16}.

xx
yy
y=xy = \sqrt{x}
2\htmlClass{lc-pink}{2}
3\htmlClass{lc-pink}{3}
4\htmlClass{lc-pink}{4}
4\htmlClass{lc-blue}{4}
9\htmlClass{lc-blue}{9}
16\htmlClass{lc-blue}{16}
5\htmlClass{lc-blue}{5}
7\htmlClass{lc-blue}{7}
x=2  ⇒  x=4x=4  ⇒  x=169−4=516−9=7\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \ep{\sqrt{x} = 2} &\;\Rightarrow\; \dl{x = 4} \\ \ep{\sqrt{x} = 4} &\;\Rightarrow\; \dl{x = 16} \\[10pt] \dl{9 - 4} &= \dl{5} \\ \dl{16 - 9} &= \dl{7} \end{aligned}

On the line, the distances to the left and right were equal. Here they are 5\dl{5} and 7\dl{7}, but ∣x−9∣<δ\dl{|x - 9| < \delta} keeps xx between 9−δ\dl{9 - \delta} and 9+δ\dl{9 + \delta}, the same distance on both sides. Should we choose δ=5\dl{\delta = 5} or δ=7\dl{\delta = 7}?

Find δ\delta for lim⁡x→9x=3\lim_{x\to 9}\sqrt{x} = 3 when ε=1\varepsilon = 1
xx
yy
y=xy = \sqrt{x}
2\htmlClass{lc-pink}{2}
3\htmlClass{lc-pink}{3}
4\htmlClass{lc-pink}{4}
ε=1\htmlClass{lc-pink}{\varepsilon = 1}
9\htmlClass{lc-blue}{9}
Text solution
δ=7\dl{\delta = 7} is too largeWith δ=7\dl{\delta = 7}, xx can go down to 2\dl{2}, and x=2.25\dl{x = 2.25} gives an output below 2\ep{2}.
δ=7:2<x<16,2.25=1.5<2\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\dl{\delta = 7}: \quad \dl{2 < x < 16}, \qquad \sqrt{\dl{2.25}} = \outs{1.5} < \ep{2}\end{aligned}
δ=7:  2<x<162.25=1.5<2\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\dl{\delta = 7}: \ \ \dl{2 < x < 16} \\ &\sqrt{\dl{2.25}} = \outs{1.5} < \ep{2} \end{aligned}
δ=5\dl{\delta = 5} worksWith δ=5\dl{\delta = 5}, every output stays between 2\ep{2} and 14\ins{\sqrt{14}}, which is less than 4\ep{4}.
δ=5:4<x<14  ⇒  2<x<14<4\displaystyle \dl{\delta = 5}: \quad \dl{4 < x < 14} \;\Rightarrow\; \ep{2} < \sqrt{x} < \ins{\sqrt{14}} < \ep{4}
δ=5:  4<x<14⇒  2<x<14<4\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\dl{\delta = 5}: \ \ \dl{4 < x < 14} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \ep{2} < \sqrt{x} < \ins{\sqrt{14}} < \ep{4} \end{aligned}
Why the left side is tighterx\sqrt{x} has a larger slope to the left of 9\dl{9}, so it drops to 2\ep{2} after only 5\dl{5} units, while it takes 7\dl{7} units on the right to reach 4\ep{4}. Any smaller δ\dl{\delta}, like 1\dl{1}, works too, and 5\dl{5} is the largest that does.
3

Showing a limit does not exist

The definition can also show that a limit doesn't exist. From the left of 0\dl{0}, this f(x)f(x) is 11, and from the right, it is 33. The number 2\ep{2} is right in the middle, so could 2\ep{2} be the limit?

f(x)={1,x<03,x≥0lim⁡x→0f(x)=2  ?\displaystyle \begin{gathered} f(x) = \begin{cases} 1, & x < 0 \\ 3, & x \ge 0 \end{cases} \\[4pt] \lim_{x\to \dl{0}} f(x) = \ep{2}\;? \end{gathered}

To show that 2\ep{2} is not the limit, we only need one ε\ep{\varepsilon} for which no δ\dl{\delta} works. With ε=12\ep{\varepsilon = \frac12}, the outputs would have to stay between 1.5\ep{1.5} and 2.5\ep{2.5}.

xx
yy
0\htmlClass{lc-blue}{0}
11
33
2\htmlClass{lc-pink}{2}
1.5\htmlClass{lc-pink}{1.5}
2.5\htmlClass{lc-pink}{2.5}
ε=12:\displaystyle \ep{\varepsilon = \tfrac12}:
∣1−2∣=1≥12∣3−2∣=1≥12\displaystyle \begin{aligned} |\outs{1} - \ep{2}| &= 1 \ge \ep{\tfrac12} \\ |\outs{3} - \ep{2}| &= 1 \ge \ep{\tfrac12} \end{aligned}
every δ>0:\displaystyle \text{every } \dl{\delta > 0}:
f(−δ2)=1f(δ2)=3\displaystyle \begin{aligned} f\big(\dl{-\tfrac{\delta}{2}}\big) &= \outs{1} \\ f\big(\dl{\tfrac{\delta}{2}}\big) &= \outs{3} \end{aligned}
Show with ε\varepsilon and δ\delta that the limit at 00 is not 22, and that no limit exists
xx
yy
0\htmlClass{lc-blue}{0}
11
33
2\htmlClass{lc-pink}{2}
f(x)={1,x<03,x≥0f(x) = \begin{cases} 1, & x < 0 \\ 3, & x \ge 0 \end{cases}
Text solution
One generous ε\ep{\varepsilon} proves nothingFor ε=1.5\ep{\varepsilon = 1.5}, both values are already inside, so every δ\dl{\delta} works. But the definition needs a δ\dl{\delta} for every positive ε\ep{\varepsilon}.
ε=1.5:0.5<1<3.5,0.5<3<3.5\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\ep{\varepsilon = 1.5}: \quad \ep{0.5} < \ins{1} < \ep{3.5}, \qquad \ep{0.5} < \ins{3} < \ep{3.5}\end{aligned}
ε=1.5:0.5<1<3.5,0.5<3<3.5\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\ep{\varepsilon = 1.5}: \\ &\ep{0.5} < \ins{1} < \ep{3.5}, \quad \ep{0.5} < \ins{3} < \ep{3.5} \end{aligned}
No δ\dl{\delta} works for ε=12\ep{\varepsilon = \frac12}However small δ\dl{\delta} is, −δ2\dl{-\frac{\delta}{2}} and δ2\dl{\frac{\delta}{2}} are within δ\dl{\delta} of 0\dl{0}, and they give 1\outs{1} and 3\outs{3}, both 11 away from 2\ep{2}. So 2\ep{2} is not the limit, and any ε≤1\ep{\varepsilon \le 1} fails the same way.
No other L\ep{L} works eitherWith ε=12\ep{\varepsilon = \frac12}, the outputs must fit between L−12\ep{L - \frac12} and L+12\ep{L + \frac12}, a range of width 1\ep{1}. It can't hold both 11 and 33, so lim⁡x→0f(x)\lim_{x\to \dl{0}} f(x) does not exist.
∣3−1∣\displaystyle |3 - 1| =2>1=2⋅12\displaystyle = 2 > \ep{1 = 2 \cdot \tfrac12}

Now try it yourself. Can you keep the outputs as close to the proposed limit as you choose?

Choosing epsilon and finding delta
4

Writing an ε\varepsilon-δ\delta proof

On y=2x+1y = 2x + 1, we found δ=ε2\dl{\delta} = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}} by testing ε=1\ep{\varepsilon = 1} and ε=0.1\ep{\varepsilon = 0.1}. A proof can't test numbers one by one. It has to give a δ\dl{\delta} for every positive ε\ep{\varepsilon}, so we need a formula for δ\dl{\delta} in terms of ε\ep{\varepsilon}.

One fact we'll use: ∣ab∣=∣a∣∣b∣|ab| = |a||b|. So when we factor a number out of an absolute value, it comes out as its absolute value, and both 2\fc{2} and −2\fc{-2} come out as 2\fc{2}.

∣2x−4∣\displaystyle \ep{|2x - 4|} =∣2∣ ∣x−2∣\displaystyle = \fc{|2|}\,\dl{|x - 2|} =2∣x−2∣\displaystyle = \fc{2}\dl{|x - 2|}
∣6−2x∣\displaystyle \ep{|6 - 2x|} =∣−2∣ ∣x−3∣\displaystyle = \fc{|-2|}\,\dl{|x - 3|} =2∣x−3∣\displaystyle = \fc{2}\dl{|x - 3|}
Prove that lim⁡x→2(2x+1)=5\lim_{x\to 2}(2x + 1) = 5 and lim⁡x→2x2−4x−2=4\lim_{x\to 2}\frac{x^2 - 4}{x - 2} = 4
lim⁡x→2(2x+1)=5:δ=  ?lim⁡x→2x2−4x−2=4:δ=  ?\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \lim_{x\to \dl{2}}(2x + 1) = \ep{5} &: \quad \dl{\delta} = \;? \\[6pt] \lim_{x\to \dl{2}}\frac{x^2 - 4}{x - 2} = \ep{4} &: \quad \dl{\delta} = \;? \end{aligned}
Text solution
Scratch work runs backwardsStart from ∣(2x+1)−5∣<ε\ep{|(2x + 1) - 5| < \varepsilon} and rewrite it until it's a condition on ∣x−2∣\dl{|x - 2|}.
∣(2x+1)−5∣\displaystyle \ep{|(2x + 1) - 5|} =∣2x−4∣\displaystyle = \ep{|2x - 4|} =2∣x−2∣\displaystyle = \fc{2}\dl{|x - 2|}
2∣x−2∣<ε  ⟺  ∣x−2∣<ε2  ⇒  δ=ε2\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\fc{2}\dl{|x - 2|} < \ep{\varepsilon} \iff \dl{|x - 2|} < \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}} \;\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta} = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}}\end{aligned}
2∣x−2∣<ε  ⟺  ∣x−2∣<ε2⇒  δ=ε2\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\fc{2}\dl{|x - 2|} < \ep{\varepsilon} \iff \dl{|x - 2|} < \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta} = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}} \end{aligned}
The fraction: x≠2\dl{x \ne 2} lets us cancelThe definition assumes 0<∣x−2∣\dl{0 < |x - 2|}, so xx is never 2\dl{2}, and the fraction is x+2x + 2. Then ∣(x+2)−4∣\ep{|(x + 2) - 4|} is just ∣x−2∣\dl{|x - 2|}, so δ=ε\dl{\delta} = \ep{\varepsilon} works.
∣x2−4x−2−4∣=∣(x+2)−4∣=∣x−2∣<δ  ⇒  δ=ε\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\ep{\left|\frac{x^2 - 4}{x - 2} - 4\right|} = \ep{|(x + 2) - 4|} = \dl{|x - 2|} < \dl{\delta} \;\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta} = \ep{\varepsilon}\end{aligned}
∣x2−4x−2−4∣=∣(x+2)−4∣=∣x−2∣<δ⇒  δ=ε\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \ep{\left|\frac{x^2 - 4}{x - 2} - 4\right|} &= \ep{|(x + 2) - 4|} \\ &= \dl{|x - 2|} < \dl{\delta} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta} = \ep{\varepsilon} \end{aligned}

Here's how the proof for 2x+12x + 1 is written up. It runs forwards, the way the definition reads: choose δ\dl{\delta}, assume 0<∣x−2∣<δ\dl{0 < |x - 2| < \delta}, and end at ∣(2x+1)−5∣<ε\ep{|(2x + 1) - 5| < \varepsilon}.

Let ε>0. Choose δ\displaystyle \text{Let } \ep{\varepsilon > 0}. \text{ Choose } \dl{\delta} =ε2.\displaystyle = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}}.
If 0<∣x−2∣<δ, then ∣(2x+1)−5∣=2∣x−2∣<2δ=ε.\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\text{If } \dl{0 < |x - 2| < \delta}, \text{ then } \ep{|(2x + 1) - 5|} = \fc{2}\dl{|x - 2|} < \fc{2}\dl{\delta} = \ep{\varepsilon}.\end{aligned}
If 0<∣x−2∣<δ, then∣(2x+1)−5∣=2∣x−2∣<2δ=ε.\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\text{If } \dl{0 < |x - 2| < \delta}, \text{ then} \\ &\ep{|(2x + 1) - 5|} = \fc{2}\dl{|x - 2|} < \fc{2}\dl{\delta} = \ep{\varepsilon}. \end{aligned}

On a test, you only hand in the proof. The scratch work is how you found δ\dl{\delta}.

5

When the factor changes with xx

For lim⁡x→3x2=9\lim_{x\to \dl{3}} x^2 = \ep{9}, the scratch work starts the same way. By the difference of squares, ∣x2−9∣\ep{|x^2 - 9|} splits into ∣x−3∣\dl{|x - 3|} times another factor.

x2−9\displaystyle x^2 - 9 =(x−3)(x+3)\displaystyle = (x - 3)(x + 3)
∣x2−9∣\displaystyle \ep{|x^2 - 9|} =∣x−3∣ ∣x+3∣\displaystyle = \dl{|x - 3|}\,\fc{|x + 3|}

For 2x+12x + 1, the factor next to ∣x−2∣\dl{|x - 2|} was the fixed number 2\fc{2}. Here ∣x+3∣\fc{|x + 3|} changes with xx, and δ\dl{\delta} has to be one number chosen before we know xx, so we can't divide ε\ep{\varepsilon} by it.

Prove that lim⁡x→3x2=9\lim_{x\to 3} x^2 = 9 using the ε\varepsilon-δ\delta definition
lim⁡x→3x2\displaystyle \lim_{x\to \dl{3}} x^2 =9:δ\displaystyle = \ep{9} : \quad \dl{\delta} =  ?\displaystyle = \;?
Text solution
Why ε6\frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{6}} isn't enoughAt x=3\dl{x = 3} the factor is 6\fc{6}, but to the right of 3\dl{3} it's larger. At the edge x=3+δ\dl{x = 3 + \delta}, ∣x2−9∣\ep{|x^2 - 9|} is already more than ε\ep{\varepsilon}, so it is at some points just inside too.
δ=ε6,  x=3+δ:∣x2−9∣=δ (6+δ)>6δ=ε\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\dl{\delta} = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{6}},\ \ \dl{x = 3 + \delta}: \quad \ep{|x^2 - 9|} = \dl{\delta}\,\fc{(6 + \delta)} > \fc{6}\dl{\delta} = \ep{\varepsilon}\end{aligned}
δ=ε6,  x=3+δ:∣x2−9∣=δ (6+δ)>6δ=ε\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\dl{\delta} = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{6}},\ \ \dl{x = 3 + \delta}: \\ &\ep{|x^2 - 9|} = \dl{\delta}\,\fc{(6 + \delta)} > \fc{6}\dl{\delta} = \ep{\varepsilon} \end{aligned}
Cap δ\dl{\delta} at 1\dl{1} to bound the factorδ\dl{\delta} is ours to choose, and a smaller δ\dl{\delta} still works, so we decide δ≤1\dl{\delta \le 1}. That keeps ∣x+3∣\fc{|x + 3|} below 7\fc{7}. A cap of 2\dl{2} would work as well, with 8\fc{8} in place of 7\fc{7}.
δ≤1:2<x<4  ⇒  5<x+3<7  ⇒  ∣x+3∣<7\displaystyle \dl{\delta \le 1}: \quad \dl{2 < x < 4} \;\Rightarrow\; \fc{5 < x + 3 < 7} \;\Rightarrow\; \fc{|x + 3| < 7}
δ≤1:  2<x<4⇒  5<x+3<7⇒  ∣x+3∣<7\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\dl{\delta \le 1}: \ \ \dl{2 < x < 4} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \fc{5 < x + 3 < 7} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \fc{|x + 3| < 7} \end{aligned}
Two jobs, so take the smallerδ≤1\dl{\delta \le 1} keeps ∣x+3∣<7\fc{|x + 3| < 7}, and δ≤ε7\dl{\delta} \le \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{7}} makes 7δ≤ε\fc{7}\dl{\delta} \le \ep{\varepsilon}. Without the cap, ε=14\ep{\varepsilon = 14} would give δ=2\dl{\delta = 2}, and x=4.9\dl{x = 4.9} gives 4.92−9=15.01>144.9^2 - 9 = \outs{15.01} > \ep{14}.
δ\displaystyle \dl{\delta} =min⁡(1,ε7)\displaystyle = \min\Big(\dl{1}, \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{7}}\Big)
The proofLet ε>0\ep{\varepsilon > 0} and choose that δ\dl{\delta}. If 0<∣x−3∣<δ\dl{0 < |x - 3| < \delta}, then ∣x−3∣<1\dl{|x - 3| < 1}, so ∣x+3∣<7\fc{|x + 3| < 7}, and
∣x2−9∣=∣x−3∣ ∣x+3∣<7∣x−3∣<7δ≤ε.\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\ep{|x^2 - 9|} = \dl{|x - 3|}\,\fc{|x + 3|} < \fc{7}\dl{|x - 3|} < \fc{7}\dl{\delta} \le \ep{\varepsilon}.\end{aligned}
∣x2−9∣=∣x−3∣ ∣x+3∣<7∣x−3∣<7δ≤ε.\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \ep{|x^2 - 9|} &= \dl{|x - 3|}\,\fc{|x + 3|} \\ &< \fc{7}\dl{|x - 3|} < \fc{7}\dl{\delta} \le \ep{\varepsilon}. \end{aligned}

Why do we need both 1\dl{1} and ε7\frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{7}}? Change ε\ep{\varepsilon} and see which one sets δ\dl{\delta}.

Two restrictions on delta

Summary

The definition of a limit
for every ε>0 there is a δ>0 such that\displaystyle \text{for every } \ep{\varepsilon > 0} \text{ there is a } \dl{\delta > 0} \text{ such that}
for every ε>0there is a δ>0 such that\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\text{for every } \ep{\varepsilon > 0} \\ &\text{there is a } \dl{\delta > 0} \text{ such that} \end{aligned}
0<∣x−a∣<δ  ⇒  ∣f(x)−L∣<ε\displaystyle \dl{0 < |x - a| < \delta} \;\Rightarrow\; \ep{|f(x) - L| < \varepsilon}
0<∣x−a∣<δ⇒  ∣f(x)−L∣<ε\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\dl{0 < |x - a| < \delta} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \ep{|f(x) - L| < \varepsilon} \end{aligned}

ε\ep{\varepsilon} is the allowed distance between f(x)f(x) and L\ep{L}, and δ\dl{\delta} is the allowed distance between xx and a\dl{a}. The target ε\ep{\varepsilon} is given first, and δ\dl{\delta} answers it. When we find a limit, we look at what happens near a\dl{a}, not at a\dl{a}. That's why we write 0<∣x−a∣\dl{0 < |x - a|}, which means we don't use x=a\dl{x = a}.

Finding δ\delta on a graph
xx
yy
y=xy = \sqrt{x}
2\htmlClass{lc-pink}{2}
3\htmlClass{lc-pink}{3}
4\htmlClass{lc-pink}{4}
4\htmlClass{lc-blue}{4}
9\htmlClass{lc-blue}{9}
16\htmlClass{lc-blue}{16}
5\htmlClass{lc-blue}{5}
7\htmlClass{lc-blue}{7}
x=2  ⇒  x=4x=4  ⇒  x=16\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \ep{\sqrt{x} = 2} &\;\Rightarrow\; \dl{x = 4} \\ \ep{\sqrt{x} = 4} &\;\Rightarrow\; \dl{x = 16} \end{aligned}
9−4=5,16−9=7\displaystyle \dl{9 - 4 = 5}, \quad \dl{16 - 9 = 7}
δ=5\displaystyle \dl{\delta = 5}

Draw horizontal lines at y=L−ε\ep{y = L - \varepsilon} and y=L+ε\ep{y = L + \varepsilon} to the curve, then vertical lines from the intersections to the x-axis to find the boundary x-values. When the two sides give different distances to a\dl{a}, choose δ\dl{\delta} to be the distance to the nearer one. For x\sqrt{x} at x=9\dl{x = 9} with ε=1\ep{\varepsilon = 1}, the boundary x-values are 4\dl{4} and 16\dl{16}, which are 5\dl{5} and 7\dl{7} units away from 9\dl{9}. We choose δ=5\dl{\delta = 5}, because the larger distance 7\dl{7} would allow inputs like x=2.25\dl{x = 2.25}, where x=1.5\sqrt{x} = \outs{1.5} is more than 1\ep{1} away from 3\ep{3}. Any smaller positive δ\dl{\delta} works too.

Showing a number is not the limit
f(x)={1,x<03,x≥0L=2\displaystyle f(x) = \begin{cases} 1, & x < 0 \\ 3, & x \ge 0 \end{cases} \quad \ep{L = 2}
ε=12:∣1−2∣=1≥12∣3−2∣=1≥12\displaystyle \ep{\varepsilon = \tfrac12}: \quad \begin{aligned} |\outs{1} - \ep{2}| &= 1 \ge \ep{\tfrac12} \\ |\outs{3} - \ep{2}| &= 1 \ge \ep{\tfrac12} \end{aligned}

To show a number L\ep{L} is not the limit, find one ε>0\ep{\varepsilon > 0} where no δ\dl{\delta} works. For this jump at 0\dl{0} with L=2\ep{L = 2}, choosing ε=12\ep{\varepsilon = \frac12} means the outputs have to be between 1.5\ep{1.5} and 2.5\ep{2.5}. Every interval around 0\dl{0} contains inputs where f(x)=1f(x) = \outs{1} and inputs where f(x)=3f(x) = \outs{3}. Both outputs are at distance 11 from 2\ep{2}, which is greater than 12\ep{\frac12}, so no δ>0\dl{\delta > 0} works.

Writing an ε\varepsilon-δ\delta proof
∣(2x+1)−5∣\displaystyle \ep{|(2x + 1) - 5|} =2∣x−2∣<ε  ⇒  δ\displaystyle = \fc{2}\dl{|x - 2|} < \ep{\varepsilon} \;\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta} =ε2\displaystyle = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}}
∣(2x+1)−5∣=2∣x−2∣<ε  ⇒  δ=ε2\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \ep{|(2x + 1) - 5|} &= \fc{2}\dl{|x - 2|} \\ &< \ep{\varepsilon} \;\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta} = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}} \end{aligned}
Let ε>0, δ=ε2:0<∣x−2∣<δ  ⇒  ∣(2x+1)−5∣=2∣x−2∣<2δ=ε\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\text{Let } \ep{\varepsilon > 0},\ \dl{\delta} = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}}: \\ &\dl{0 < |x - 2| < \delta} \;\Rightarrow\; \ep{|(2x + 1) - 5|} = \fc{2}\dl{|x - 2|} < \fc{2}\dl{\delta} = \ep{\varepsilon} \end{aligned}
Let ε>0, δ=ε2:0<∣x−2∣<δ  ⇒∣(2x+1)−5∣=2∣x−2∣<2δ=ε\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\text{Let } \ep{\varepsilon > 0},\ \dl{\delta} = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}}: \\ &\dl{0 < |x - 2| < \delta} \;\Rightarrow \\ &\ep{|(2x + 1) - 5|} = \fc{2}\dl{|x - 2|} \\ &\qquad < \fc{2}\dl{\delta} = \ep{\varepsilon} \end{aligned}

To find δ\dl{\delta}, work backwards from ∣f(x)−L∣<ε\ep{|f(x) - L| < \varepsilon} to isolate ∣x−a∣\dl{|x - a|}. When ∣f(x)−L∣\ep{|f(x) - L|} simplifies to a constant times ∣x−a∣\dl{|x - a|}, divide ε\ep{\varepsilon} by that constant to get δ\dl{\delta}. For 2x+12x + 1 near 2\dl{2}, factoring out 2\fc{2} gives 2∣x−2∣<ε\fc{2}\dl{|x - 2|} < \ep{\varepsilon}, so δ=ε2\dl{\delta} = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}}. Then write the proof forwards. Let ε>0\ep{\varepsilon > 0}, choose that δ\dl{\delta}, and show that 0<∣x−a∣<δ\dl{0 < |x - a| < \delta} leads to ∣f(x)−L∣<ε\ep{|f(x) - L| < \varepsilon}.

When a factor changes with xx
∣x2−9∣\displaystyle \ep{|x^2 - 9|} =∣x−3∣ ∣x+3∣\displaystyle = \dl{|x - 3|}\,\fc{|x + 3|}
δ≤1  ⇒  5<x+3<7\displaystyle \dl{\delta \le 1} \;\Rightarrow\; \fc{5 < x + 3 < 7}
δ\displaystyle \dl{\delta} =min⁡(1,ε7)\displaystyle = \min\Big(\dl{1}, \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{7}}\Big)

When ∣f(x)−L∣\ep{|f(x) - L|} factors into ∣x−a∣\dl{|x - a|} times an expression that changes with xx, choose a restriction like δ≤1\dl{\delta \le 1} to keep that factor below a fixed number. For x2x^2 near 3\dl{3}, setting δ≤1\dl{\delta \le 1} keeps xx between 2\dl{2} and 4\dl{4}, so ∣x+3∣<7\fc{|x + 3| < 7}. That gives ∣x2−9∣<7∣x−3∣\ep{|x^2 - 9|} < \fc{7}\dl{|x - 3|}, so choosing δ=min⁡(1,ε7)\dl{\delta} = \min\left(\dl{1}, \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{7}}\right) guarantees ∣x2−9∣<ε\ep{|x^2 - 9| < \varepsilon}.

6

Practice

For Problems 1 and 2, enter your answer as an exact decimal. For Problems 3 to 8, write out your scratch work and proof, then check your steps against the solution.

1
For lim⁡x→3(5−2x)=−1\lim_{x\to 3}(5 - 2x) = -1 and ε=0.01\varepsilon = 0.01, find the largest δ\delta such that 0<∣x−3∣<δ0 < |x - 3| < \delta implies ∣(5−2x)−(−1)∣<0.01|(5 - 2x) - (-1)| < 0.01.

How can you factor ∣6−2x∣|6 - 2x| into a number times ∣x−3∣|x - 3|?

The slope is −2-2, so the output changes twice as fast as xx. Does δ\delta need to be half of ε\varepsilon or twice ε\varepsilon?

Write the distance from the output to the limit in terms of ∣x−3∣\dl{|x - 3|}.
∣(5−2x)−(−1)∣=∣6−2x∣=∣−2∣ ∣x−3∣=2∣x−3∣\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \ep{|(5 - 2x) - (-1)|} &= \ep{|6 - 2x|} \\ &= \fc{|-2|}\,\dl{|x - 3|} = \fc{2}\dl{|x - 3|} \end{aligned}
We need this distance to be less than 0.01\ep{0.01}, so divide by 2\fc{2}.
2∣x−3∣<0.01  ⟺  ∣x−3∣<0.005⇒  δ=0.005\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\fc{2}\dl{|x - 3|} < \ep{0.01} \iff \dl{|x - 3| < 0.005} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta = 0.005} \end{aligned}
2
The graph of f(x)=6xf(x) = \dfrac{6}{x} near x=3x = 3 is shown with the lines y=1.5y = 1.5 and y=2.5y = 2.5. Find the largest δ\delta such that 0<∣x−3∣<δ0 < |x - 3| < \delta implies ∣6x−2∣<0.5\left|\dfrac{6}{x} - 2\right| < 0.5.
xx
yy
22
33
44
55
1.5\htmlClass{lc-pink}{1.5}
22
2.5\htmlClass{lc-pink}{2.5}
y=2.5\htmlClass{lc-pink}{y = 2.5}
y=1.5\htmlClass{lc-pink}{y = 1.5}
y=6xy = \dfrac{6}{x}

What xx-values give 6x=2.5\frac{6}{x} = 2.5 and 6x=1.5\frac{6}{x} = 1.5?

Which endpoint, x=2.4x = 2.4 or x=4x = 4, is nearer to 33?

Find the endpointsSet 6x\frac{6}{x} equal to the two bounds on yy, 2.5\ep{2.5} and 1.5\ep{1.5}.
6x=2.5  ⇒  x=2.46x=1.5  ⇒  x=4\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \frac{6}{x} = \ep{2.5} &\;\Rightarrow\; \dl{x = 2.4} \\ \frac{6}{x} = \ep{1.5} &\;\Rightarrow\; \dl{x = 4} \end{aligned}
Choose the nearer distanceFind the distance from 3\dl{3} to each endpoint, then pick the smaller one so the outputs on both sides stay between 1.5\ep{1.5} and 2.5\ep{2.5}.
3−2.4=0.6,4−3=1⇒  δ=0.6\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\dl{3 - 2.4 = 0.6}, \quad \dl{4 - 3 = 1} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta = 0.6} \end{aligned}
Taking δ=1\dl{\delta = 1} would include x=2.2\dl{x = 2.2}, where the output is above 2.5\ep{2.5}.
δ=1:  x=2.262.2=3011>2.5\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\dl{\delta = 1}: \ \ \dl{x = 2.2} \\ &\frac{6}{\dl{2.2}} = \outs{\frac{30}{11}} > \ep{2.5} \end{aligned}
3
Use the ε-δ definition to prove that lim⁡x→−2(12x+3)=2\lim_{x\to -2}\left(\tfrac12 x + 3\right) = 2.

What is the distance ∣x−a∣|x - a| when a=−2a = -2?

Factor 12\frac12 out of 12x+1\frac12 x + 1, then take the absolute value to get a multiple of ∣x+2∣|x + 2|.

If you got ∣x−2∣|x - 2| in the proof Check the sign of aa. Since a=−2a = -2, the distance from xx to aa is ∣x−(−2)∣=∣x+2∣|x - (-2)| = |x + 2|.

If you got δ=ε2\delta = \dfrac{\varepsilon}{2} While δ=ε2\delta = \frac{\varepsilon}{2} is small enough to work, check how you solved 12∣x+2∣<ε\frac12|x + 2| < \varepsilon in your scratch work.

Scratch workWrite the distance from xx to −2\dl{-2}, and simplify the difference between the output and the limit.
∣x−(−2)∣=∣x+2∣∣(12x+3)−2∣=∣12x+1∣=12∣x+2∣\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \dl{|x - (-2)|} &= \dl{|x + 2|} \\ \ep{\left|\left(\tfrac12 x + 3\right) - 2\right|} &= \ep{\left|\tfrac12 x + 1\right|} = \fc{\tfrac12}\dl{|x + 2|} \end{aligned}
Choose δ\deltaWe want 12∣x+2∣<ε\fc{\frac12}\dl{|x + 2|} < \ep{\varepsilon}, so multiply both sides by 22.
12∣x+2∣<ε  ⟺  ∣x+2∣<2ε⇒  δ=2ε\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\fc{\tfrac12}\dl{|x + 2|} < \ep{\varepsilon} \iff \dl{|x + 2|} < \fc{2}\ep{\varepsilon} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta} = \fc{2}\ep{\varepsilon} \end{aligned}
Write the proofNow write the steps in the order of the definition.
Let ε>0. Choose δ=2ε.If 0<∣x+2∣<δ, then∣(12x+3)−2∣=12∣x+2∣<12δ=ε.\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\text{Let } \ep{\varepsilon > 0}. \text{ Choose } \dl{\delta} = \fc{2}\ep{\varepsilon}. \\ &\text{If } \dl{0 < |x + 2| < \delta}, \text{ then} \\ &\ep{\left|\left(\tfrac12 x + 3\right) - 2\right|} = \fc{\tfrac12}\dl{|x + 2|} \\ &\qquad < \fc{\tfrac12}\dl{\delta} = \ep{\varepsilon}. \end{aligned}
4
Use the ε-δ definition to prove that lim⁡x→32x2−5x−3x−3=7\displaystyle\lim_{x\to 3}\frac{2x^2 - 5x - 3}{x - 3} = 7.

How does 2x2−5x−32x^2 - 5x - 3 factor when one factor is x−3x - 3?

Why can we cancel x−3x - 3? What does 0<∣x−3∣0 < |x - 3| say about xx?

If you got δ=ε\delta = \varepsilon Check your factoring of ∣2x−6∣|2x - 6|. Factoring out 22 gives 2∣x−3∣2|x - 3|, not ∣x−3∣|x - 3|.

Simplify the fractionThe condition 0<∣x−3∣\dl{0 < |x - 3|} means x≠3\dl{x \ne 3}, so we can cancel x−3x - 3 from the numerator and denominator.
2x2−5x−3=(2x+1)(x−3)0<∣x−3∣  ⇒  x≠3⇒  2x2−5x−3x−3=2x+1\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &2x^2 - 5x - 3 = (2x + 1)(x - 3) \\ &\dl{0 < |x - 3|} \;\Rightarrow\; \dl{x \ne 3} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \frac{2x^2 - 5x - 3}{x - 3} = 2x + 1 \end{aligned}
Scratch work for δ\deltaFactor out 2\fc{2}, then divide by 2\fc{2} to isolate ∣x−3∣\dl{|x - 3|}.
∣(2x+1)−7∣=∣2x−6∣=2∣x−3∣<ε  ⟺  ∣x−3∣<ε2  ⇒  δ=ε2\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \ep{|(2x + 1) - 7|} &= \ep{|2x - 6|} \\ &= \fc{2}\dl{|x - 3|} < \ep{\varepsilon} \\ &\iff \dl{|x - 3|} < \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}} \;\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta} = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}} \end{aligned}
Write the proofChoose δ=ε2\dl{\delta} = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}} and show that ∣f(x)−7∣<ε\ep{|f(x) - 7| < \varepsilon} whenever 0<∣x−3∣<δ\dl{0 < |x - 3| < \delta}.
Let ε>0. Choose δ=ε2.If 0<∣x−3∣<δ, then∣2x2−5x−3x−3−7∣=2∣x−3∣<2δ=ε.\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\text{Let } \ep{\varepsilon > 0}. \text{ Choose } \dl{\delta} = \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{2}}. \\ &\text{If } \dl{0 < |x - 3| < \delta}, \text{ then} \\ &\ep{\left|\frac{2x^2 - 5x - 3}{x - 3} - 7\right|} = \fc{2}\dl{|x - 3|} \\ &\qquad < \fc{2}\dl{\delta} = \ep{\varepsilon}. \end{aligned}
5
Use the ε-δ definition to prove that lim⁡x→1(x2+x)=2\lim_{x\to 1}(x^2 + x) = 2.

Factor x2+x−2x^2 + x - 2 into (x−1)(x - 1) times another factor.

If xx is within 11 of 11, how large can x+2x + 2 be?

If you got δ=ε3\delta = \dfrac{\varepsilon}{3} x+2x + 2 is only 33 at x=1x = 1. For ε=3\varepsilon = 3, δ=ε3=1\delta = \frac{\varepsilon}{3} = 1 allows x=1.9x = 1.9, where ∣f(1.9)−2∣=3.51>3|f(1.9) - 2| = 3.51 > 3.

Factor the differenceFactor the quadratic to separate the distance ∣x−1∣\dl{|x - 1|} from the changing factor ∣x+2∣\fc{|x + 2|}.
∣(x2+x)−2∣=∣x2+x−2∣=∣x−1∣ ∣x+2∣\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \ep{|(x^2 + x) - 2|} &= \ep{|x^2 + x - 2|} \\ &= \dl{|x - 1|}\,\fc{|x + 2|} \end{aligned}
Bound the changing factorChoose δ≤1\dl{\delta \le 1} first, so xx is between 0\dl{0} and 2\dl{2}. That puts a bound of 4\fc{4} on ∣x+2∣\fc{|x + 2|}.
δ≤1:  0<x<2⇒  2<x+2<4  ⇒  ∣x+2∣<4\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\dl{\delta \le 1}: \ \ \dl{0 < x < 2} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \fc{2 < x + 2 < 4} \;\Rightarrow\; \fc{|x + 2| < 4} \end{aligned}
Choose δ\deltaWe need δ≤1\dl{\delta \le 1} and 4δ≤ε\fc{4}\dl{\delta} \le \ep{\varepsilon}, so take the minimum of 1\dl{1} and ε4\frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{4}}.
∣x2+x−2∣<4∣x−1∣<4δ≤εwhen δ≤ε4⇒  δ=min⁡(1,ε4)\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \ep{|x^2 + x - 2|} &< \fc{4}\dl{|x - 1|} < \fc{4}\dl{\delta} \\ &\le \ep{\varepsilon} \quad \text{when } \dl{\delta} \le \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{4}} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta} = \min\Big(\dl{1}, \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{4}}\Big) \end{aligned}
Write the proofCombine the bound on ∣x+2∣\fc{|x + 2|} with δ≤ε4\dl{\delta} \le \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{4}} to complete the proof.
Let ε>0. Choose δ=min⁡(1,ε4).If 0<∣x−1∣<δ,then ∣x+2∣<4 and∣(x2+x)−2∣=∣x−1∣ ∣x+2∣<4δ≤ε.\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\text{Let } \ep{\varepsilon > 0}. \text{ Choose } \dl{\delta} = \min\Big(\dl{1}, \frac{\ep{\varepsilon}}{\fc{4}}\Big). \\ &\text{If } \dl{0 < |x - 1| < \delta}, \\ &\text{then } \fc{|x + 2| < 4} \text{ and} \\ &\ep{|(x^2 + x) - 2|} = \dl{|x - 1|}\,\fc{|x + 2|} \\ &\qquad < \fc{4}\dl{\delta} \le \ep{\varepsilon}. \end{aligned}
6
Let f(x)=x+1f(x) = x + 1 for x<1x < 1 and f(x)=5−xf(x) = 5 - x for x≥1x \ge 1. Use the ε-δ definition to show that lim⁡x→1f(x)\lim_{x\to 1} f(x) is not 44.
xx
yy
11
22
44
y=x+1y = x + 1
y=5−xy = 5 - x

What value does f(x)f(x) approach as xx approaches 11 from the left?

The left-hand limit is 22 and the proposed limit is 44. Pick ε\varepsilon small enough that 4−ε≥24 - \varepsilon \ge 2.

If you got ε=3\varepsilon = 3 Check whether any outputs miss the interval (4−3,4+3)=(1,7)(4 - 3, 4 + 3) = (1, 7). For 0<x<10 < x < 1, f(x)=x+1f(x) = x + 1 is between 11 and 22, which is inside (1,7)(1, 7), so ε=3\varepsilon = 3 is too large to disprove the limit.

Check the one-sided limitsAs xx approaches 1\dl{1} from the left, f(x)f(x) approaches 22, not 4\ep{4}. The value f(1)=4f(1) = 4 plays no role, because limits require x≠1\dl{x \ne 1}.
x→1−:  x+1→2x→1+:  5−x→4f(1)=4\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &x \to \dl{1}^-: \ \ x + 1 \to 2 \\ &x \to \dl{1}^+: \ \ 5 - x \to 4 \\ &f(1) = 4 \end{aligned}
Pick an ε\varepsilon for which no δ\delta worksChoose ε=1\ep{\varepsilon = 1}, which requires 3<f(x)<5\ep{3 < f(x) < 5}. For any δ>0\dl{\delta > 0}, we can choose an input within that distance to the left of 1\dl{1}, where the output is below 22.
ε=1:  3<f(x)<5every δ>0:  x=1−δ2f(x)=2−δ2<2<3\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\ep{\varepsilon = 1}: \ \ \ep{3 < f(x) < 5} \\ &\text{every } \dl{\delta > 0}: \ \ \dl{x = 1 - \tfrac{\delta}{2}} \\ &f(x) = \outs{2 - \tfrac{\delta}{2}} < 2 < \ep{3} \end{aligned}
No positive δ\dl{\delta} keeps the outputs inside (3,5)\ep{(3, 5)}, so the limit can't be 4\ep{4}.
no δ for ε=1  ⇒  lim⁡x→1f(x)≠4\displaystyle \text{no } \dl{\delta} \text{ for } \ep{\varepsilon = 1} \;\Rightarrow\; \lim_{x\to \dl{1}} f(x) \ne \ep{4}
7
Use the ε-δ definition to prove that lim⁡x→21x=12\displaystyle\lim_{x\to 2}\frac{1}{x} = \frac12.

Find a common denominator for 1x−12\frac{1}{x} - \frac12.

If we choose δ≤1\delta \le 1, how small can xx get when xx is within 11 of 22?

If you got δ=min⁡(1,6ε)\delta = \min(1, 6\varepsilon) When x<3x < 3, 12x\frac{1}{2x} is greater than 16\frac16, not less than 16\frac16. To bound 12∣x∣\frac{1}{2|x|} from above, use the lower bound x>1x > 1.

Combine over a common denominatorSubtract the fractions, and note that ∣2−x∣=∣x−2∣\dl{|2 - x| = |x - 2|}.
∣1x−12∣\displaystyle \ep{\left|\frac1x - \frac12\right|} =∣2−x2x∣\displaystyle = \left|\frac{2 - x}{2x}\right| =∣x−2∣2∣x∣\displaystyle = \frac{\dl{|x - 2|}}{\fc{2|x|}}
Bound the denominatorRequire δ≤1\dl{\delta \le 1} so that x>1\dl{x > 1}. That keeps the denominator from getting too small.
δ≤1:  1<x<3⇒  2∣x∣>2  ⇒  12∣x∣<12\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\dl{\delta \le 1}: \ \ \dl{1 < x < 3} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \fc{2|x| > 2} \;\Rightarrow\; \fc{\frac{1}{2|x|} < \frac12} \end{aligned}
Choose δ\deltaWith 12∣x∣<12\fc{\frac{1}{2|x|} < \frac12}, we need 12δ≤ε\fc{\frac12}\dl{\delta} \le \ep{\varepsilon}, so choose the smaller of 1\dl{1} and 2ε\fc{2}\ep{\varepsilon}.
∣1x−12∣<12∣x−2∣<12δ≤εwhen δ≤2ε⇒  δ=min⁡(1,2ε)\displaystyle \begin{aligned} \ep{\left|\frac1x - \frac12\right|} &< \fc{\frac12}\dl{|x - 2|} < \fc{\frac12}\dl{\delta} \\ &\le \ep{\varepsilon} \quad \text{when } \dl{\delta} \le \fc{2}\ep{\varepsilon} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta} = \min(\dl{1}, \fc{2}\ep{\varepsilon}) \end{aligned}
Write the proofCombine x>1\dl{x > 1} with δ≤2ε\dl{\delta} \le \fc{2}\ep{\varepsilon} to complete the proof.
Let ε>0. Choose δ=min⁡(1,2ε).If 0<∣x−2∣<δ, then x>1 and∣1x−12∣=∣x−2∣2∣x∣<12δ≤ε.\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\text{Let } \ep{\varepsilon > 0}. \text{ Choose } \dl{\delta} = \min(\dl{1}, \fc{2}\ep{\varepsilon}). \\ &\text{If } \dl{0 < |x - 2| < \delta}, \text{ then } \dl{x > 1} \text{ and} \\ &\ep{\left|\frac1x - \frac12\right|} = \frac{\dl{|x - 2|}}{\fc{2|x|}} < \fc{\frac12}\dl{\delta} \le \ep{\varepsilon}. \end{aligned}
8
Use the ε-δ definition to prove that lim⁡x→9x=3\lim_{x\to 9}\sqrt{x} = 3. (Challenge)

What happens when you multiply x−3\sqrt{x} - 3 by its conjugate x+3\sqrt{x} + 3?

What is the smallest possible value of the denominator x+3\sqrt{x} + 3?

Multiply by the conjugateMultiply and divide by x+3\fc{\sqrt{x} + 3} to turn the numerator into ∣x−9∣\dl{|x - 9|}.
∣x−3∣\displaystyle \ep{|\sqrt{x} - 3|} =∣x−3∣ (x+3)x+3\displaystyle = \frac{\ep{|\sqrt{x} - 3|}\,\fc{(\sqrt{x} + 3)}}{\fc{\sqrt{x} + 3}} =∣x−9∣x+3\displaystyle = \frac{\dl{|x - 9|}}{\fc{\sqrt{x} + 3}}
Bound the denominatorBecause x≥0\sqrt{x} \ge 0, the denominator is at least 3\fc{3}, so dividing by it gives at most ∣x−9∣3\frac{\dl{|x - 9|}}{\fc{3}}.
x+3≥3  ⇒  ∣x−3∣\displaystyle \fc{\sqrt{x} + 3 \ge 3} \;\Rightarrow\; \ep{|\sqrt{x} - 3|} ≤∣x−9∣3\displaystyle \le \frac{\dl{|x - 9|}}{\fc{3}}
Choose δ\deltaSet δ≤9\dl{\delta \le 9} so that x>0\dl{x > 0} and the square root is defined, then solve δ3≤ε\frac{\dl{\delta}}{\fc{3}} \le \ep{\varepsilon}.
δ≤9  ⇒  x>0∣x−9∣3<δ3≤εwhen δ≤3ε⇒  δ=min⁡(9,3ε)\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\dl{\delta \le 9} \;\Rightarrow\; \dl{x > 0} \\ &\frac{\dl{|x - 9|}}{\fc{3}} < \frac{\dl{\delta}}{\fc{3}} \le \ep{\varepsilon} \quad \text{when } \dl{\delta} \le \fc{3}\ep{\varepsilon} \\ &\Rightarrow\; \dl{\delta} = \min(\dl{9}, \fc{3}\ep{\varepsilon}) \end{aligned}
Write the proofChoose δ=min⁡(9,3ε)\dl{\delta} = \min(\dl{9}, \fc{3}\ep{\varepsilon}) and verify that 0<∣x−9∣<δ\dl{0 < |x - 9| < \delta} implies ∣x−3∣<ε\ep{|\sqrt{x} - 3| < \varepsilon}.
Let ε>0. Choose δ=min⁡(9,3ε).If 0<∣x−9∣<δ, then x>0 and∣x−3∣≤∣x−9∣3<δ3≤ε.\displaystyle \begin{aligned} &\text{Let } \ep{\varepsilon > 0}. \text{ Choose } \dl{\delta} = \min(\dl{9}, \fc{3}\ep{\varepsilon}). \\ &\text{If } \dl{0 < |x - 9| < \delta}, \text{ then } \dl{x > 0} \text{ and} \\ &\ep{|\sqrt{x} - 3|} \le \frac{\dl{|x - 9|}}{\fc{3}} < \frac{\dl{\delta}}{\fc{3}} \le \ep{\varepsilon}. \end{aligned}
Notice that for ε=1\ep{\varepsilon = 1}, this gives δ=3\dl{\delta = 3}, which is smaller than the largest working value of 5\dl{5} from the graph. The proof only requires a δ\dl{\delta} that works, not the biggest one.
ε=1:δ\displaystyle \ep{\varepsilon = 1}: \quad \dl{\delta} =min⁡(9,3)\displaystyle = \min(\dl{9}, \dl{3}) =3<5\displaystyle = \dl{3} < \dl{5}