Let's find the area under y=x21 to the right of x=1. The region never stops, so we write ∞ for the upper bound. We can't plug ∞ into an antiderivative, because infinity isn't a number. But we can stop at a right edge b>1, where the area is an ordinary integral that we already know how to compute.
∫1bx21dx=[−x1]1b=1−b1
Then we watch what that area does as b moves out, and try the same thing on y=x1.
Find the area under y=x21 and y=x1 for x≥1
Text solution
Let b go to infinitySince b1 is positive, the area out to b stays below 1:0.9, then 0.99, then 0.999. And as b1 goes to 0, the area approaches 1.
∫1∞x21dx=b→∞lim(1−b1)=1
The same steps for x1The antiderivative is lnx, and ln1=0, so the area out to b is lnb. It grows without bound, so the integral diverges.
∫1∞x1dx=b→∞limlnb=∞
Both curves approach 0, yet one area is 1 and the other is infinite. So the curve approaching 0 doesn't tell us whether the area is finite. We have to take the limit, and that limit is how we define any integral with ∞ as a bound.
Integral to infinity
∫a∞f(x)dx=b→∞lim∫abf(x)dx
∫a∞f(x)dx=b→∞lim∫abf(x)dx
When the limit is a finite number, we say the integral converges. If the limit is infinite, or if there's no limit at all, we say the integral diverges.
2
Why x21 has finite area and x1 doesn't
So why is one area 1 and the other infinite? Let's cut both regions at x=1,2,4,8, and so on, so that each piece is twice as wide as the one before it, and see what happens to the heights.
Why ∫1∞x2dx is finite and ∫1∞xdx is infinite
Text solution
For x1, every piece is the sameDoubling x cuts the height in half, while the width doubles. So every piece has area ln2, and adding ln2 forever gives infinity.
2x1=21⋅x1
∫12x1dx=∫24x1dx=ln2
For x21, each piece is half the one beforeDoubling x divides the height by 4, while the width only doubles. The running totals are 1−b1, which approach 1.
(2x)21=41⋅x21
21+41+81+⋯=1
Any power pEach time x doubles, the area of a piece is multiplied by 21−p, which is less than 1 only when p>1. Integrating out to b gives the same rule.
2⋅2p1=21−p
∫1∞xpdx=p−11(p>1)
So the power of x decides it. The area is finite only when the height falls faster than the pieces widen, and that happens when p>1.
∫1∞xp1dx:p>1→convergesp≤1→diverges
3
An infinitely tall region
A region can also be infinitely tall. As x approaches 0 from the right, x1 goes to infinity, so the region under it from 0 to 1 has a vertical asymptote at x=0. Just as we set a right edge at b when a region stretched infinitely far to the right, we set a left edge at a, between 0 and 1, and let it approach 0. Let's do it for x1 and for x21.
∫a1x−21dx=2−2a
∫a1x−2dx=a1−1
a410.010.00012−2a11.81.98a1−13999999
Find the area under y=x1 from x=0 to x=1, and compare it with x21
1
2
1
2
3
4
x
x1
Text solution
Let a approach 0As a→0+,2a goes to 0, so this infinitely tall region has area 2. For x21,a1 goes to infinity.
∫01x1dx=a→0+lim(2−2a)=2
∫01x21dx=a→0+lim(a1−1)=∞
Cut toward 0Each piece is half as wide as the one to its right, and halving x multiplies the height of xp1 by 2p. For x1, each piece is about 0.71 times the one to its right. For x21, it's twice as big.
21⋅221≈0.71
21⋅22=2
Any power pAs a→0+,a1−p goes to 0 only when p<1. At p=1,−lna goes to infinity.
∫01xpdx=1−p1(p<1)
Earlier, on [1,∞), the integral of x21 converged and the integral of x1 diverged. Between 0 and 1, it's the other way round. Cutting toward 0, the pieces under x1 get smaller, and their totals approach 2.
1
21
41
81
x
y
0.59
0.41
0.29
x1
0.59+0.411+0.29=1=2−241=1.29≈2−281
Every curve xp1 passes through (1,1). To the right of 1, a larger power p makes the curve lower. Between 0 and 1, a larger p makes it taller.
1
2
21
1
x
2
∞
∞
∞
∞
1
4
2
≈1.41
≈0.71
0.5
0.25
x1
x1
x21
x1
x21
So the tail converges when p>1, the part from 0 to 1 converges when p<1, and at p=1, both diverge.
The tail
∫1∞xp1dx
p>1p≤1→converges→diverges
∫1∞x2dx=1
The part from 0 to 1
∫01xp1dx
p<1p≥1→converges→diverges
∫01xdx=2
Do we use the same rule near zero and at infinity?
Compare the two areas
4
A vertical asymptote inside the interval
Let's find the integral of x21 from −1 to 1. Both bounds are ordinary numbers, with no infinity in sight, so you might try the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus straight away.
∫−11x21dx=[−x1]−11=−1−1=−2
−1
1
x
y
x21
Wait. Negative 2? For every x=0,x21 is positive, so the area can't be negative. The trouble is at x=0, right between the bounds.
Evaluate ∫−11x21dx and ∫03(x−1)32dx, or show that they diverge
∫−11x21dx∫03(x−1)32dx=?=?
Text solution
Split at the asymptoteF(b)−F(a) works only when the function is continuous on the whole interval, and x21 has a vertical asymptote at x=0. The piece from 0 to 1 has p=2, so it diverges, and so does the whole integral.
∫−11x21dx=∫−10x21dx+∫01x21dx
Split ∫03 at x=1The denominator of (x−1)321 is 0 at x=1. With the antiderivative 3(x−1)31, each piece takes its limit from inside, and both are finite.
∫01(x−1)32dx=3
∫13(x−1)32dx=332
Add the piecesBoth pieces converge because the power 32 is less than 1.
∫03(x−1)32dx=3+332
5
When both ends are infinite
Now both bounds are infinite. Each infinite end needs its own limit, so just as with an asymptote inside the interval, we split the integral into two pieces, with one infinite end on each. Any split point works, but 0 is the easiest choice.
−5
5
x
1+x21
2π
−2π
arctanx
Find ∫−∞∞1+x21dx and check whether ∫−∞∞xdx converges
0
x
1+x21
Text solution
Split at 0The antiderivative is arctanx, which approaches 2π as x→∞ and −2π as x→−∞. So each half converges to 2π.
∫−∞01+x2dx=2π
∫0∞1+x2dx=2π
∫−∞∞1+x2dx=2π+2π=π
Split ∫xdx at 0 tooThe right half diverges on its own, so ∫−∞∞xdx diverges.
∫0∞xdx=b→∞lim2b2=∞
Why not take one limit, from −b to b? For y=x, the areas below and above the x-axis cancel for every b. But if the right end moves out twice as fast, the integral goes to infinity instead. The answer depends on how the ends go out, so there's no single value. When both halves converge on their own, as they do for 1+x21, it doesn't matter.
−b
b
y=x
−b
2b
y=x
∫−bbxdx=2b2−b2=0
∫−b2bxdx=24b2−b2=23b2
If the positive and negative areas cancel, does the integral converge?
Move the two bounds independently
6
Limits after integrating
In these three integrals, integrating up to b is routine. The hard part is the limit at the end: one gives ∞⋅0, one gives ∞−∞, and one keeps oscillating.
Evaluate ∫0∞xe−xdx,∫2∞x2−1dx, and ∫0∞cosxdx, or show that they diverge
∫0∞xe−xdx∫2∞x2−11dx∫0∞cosxdx=?=?=?
Text solution
∞⋅0: write it as a fractionBy parts, the area out to b is 1−be−b−e−b. The product be−b gives ∞⋅0, so we write it as ebb and use L'Hôpital's rule.
b→∞limebb=b→∞limeb1=0
∫0∞xe−xdx=1
∞−∞: combine the logsPartial fractions gives two logarithms that both go to infinity. With lnA−lnB=lnBA, they become one logarithm that goes to 21ln1=0, and the 21ln3 from x=2 is left.
21lnb+1b−1→0
∫2∞x2−1dx=21ln3
No limit at allThe integral of cosx out to b is sinb, which keeps oscillating between −1 and 1. The limit doesn't exist, so the integral diverges, even though nothing goes to infinity.
∫0∞cosxdx=b→∞limsinb
7
Comparing with known integrals
None of our integration methods give an antiderivative for e−x2. But to know whether the integral converges, we only need to know whether the area is finite, and we can find that out by comparing it with a curve we can integrate.
1
2
3
4
x
y
e−x
e−x2
e1
x≥1:x2≥xe−x2≤e−x
∫1∞e−xdx=b→∞lim(e−1−e−b)=e1
Sometimes two comparisons are possible, and only one of them proves anything.
1
2
3
4
5
6
1
x
y
∞
∞
1
x1
x1
x21
x2+x1
x2+x1<x21∫1∞x2dx=1
x2+x1<x1∫1∞xdx=∞
Decide whether ∫1∞e−x2dx,∫1∞x2+xdx, and ∫1∞x2+cosxdx converge
∫1∞e−x2dx∫1∞x2+xdx∫1∞x2+cosxdx=?=?=?
Text solution
Below a curve with finite areaFor x≥1,x2≥x, so e−x2≤e−x. The area under e−x is e1, so the integral converges, even though we don't know its exact value.
∫1∞e−x2dx≤∫1∞e−xdx=e1
Choose the comparison from the largest termAt x=100,x2+x=10,010, so the denominator behaves like x2 and we expect convergence. So we compare with x21. Being below x1, which has infinite area, proves nothing.
x2+x1<x21
∫1∞x2dx=1
Above a curve with infinite areaSince cosx≥−1, the numerator 2+cosx is at least 1. So the curve stays above x1, and the integral diverges.
x2+cosx≥x1
∫1∞xdx=∞
A comparison only proves convergence or divergence when the inequality goes the right way.
What works
below a curve with finite areaabove a curve with infinite area→converges→diverges
below a curve with finite area→convergesabove a curve with infinite area→diverges
What doesn't work
below a curve with infinite area,or above a curve with finite area→no conclusion
Both comparisons are true. Which one tells us whether the integral converges?
Check the direction
Summary
What makes an improper integral converge
An infinite bound
∫1∞x21dx=b→∞lim∫1bx21dx=b→∞lim(1−b1)=1
∫1∞x21dx=b→∞lim∫1bx21dx=b→∞lim(1−b1)=1
A vertical asymptote
∫01x1dx=a→0+lim(2−2a)=2
∫01x1dx=a→0+lim(2−2a)=2
An improper integral is a limit of ordinary definite integrals. Replace an infinite upper bound with b, integrate up to b, and take the limit as b goes to infinity. When a curve has a vertical asymptote at an endpoint, replace that endpoint with a variable and approach it from inside the interval.
If the limit is a finite number, the integral converges to that number. If the limit is infinite or doesn't exist, the integral diverges.
Powers of x at infinity and near zero
1
1
x
y
x1
x21
The tail from 1 to infinity
∫1∞xp1dxp>1→converges
The part from 0 to 1
∫01xp1dxp<1→converges
Every curve y=xp1 passes through (1,1). To the right of 1, a larger power p makes xp1 smaller, so the tail approaches 0 fast enough to have finite area when p>1. Between 0 and 1, a larger power makes the curve taller, but the area from 0 to 1 is finite when p<1, even if the curve goes to infinity near zero. At p=1, both areas are infinite.
A vertical asymptote inside the bounds
∫−11x21dx=∫−10x21dx+∫01x21dx,∫01x21dx=∞
∫−11x21dx∫01x21dx=∫−10x21dx+∫01x21dx=∞
Check the interval before using an antiderivative. The Fundamental Theorem of Calculus requires the function to be continuous on the entire interval [a,b]. If there is a vertical asymptote between the bounds, split the integral at that point and evaluate each piece with its own limit. If any piece diverges, the whole integral diverges.
Two infinite ends
∫−bbxdx=0,∫0∞xdx=∞
∫−bbxdx=0∫0∞xdx=∞
When both bounds are infinite, split the integral at any middle point into two pieces, each with one infinite bound. Don't just integrate from −b to b and let b go to infinity. For f(x)=x, that symmetric limit gives 0, but the right-hand piece ∫0∞xdx is infinite, so ∫−∞∞xdx diverges. Because we can move the two bounds outward at different rates, both pieces must converge on their own.
Finishing the limit
0 times infinity
b→∞limbe−b=b→∞limebb=b→∞limeb1=0
b→∞limbe−b=b→∞limebb=b→∞limeb1=0
Infinity minus infinity
21(ln(b−1)−ln(b+1))=21lnb+1b−1→0
21(ln(b−1)−ln(b+1))=21lnb+1b−1→0
If you get ∞⋅0, rewrite the product as a fraction like ebb and use L'Hôpital's rule. If you get ∞−∞ between logarithms, combine them with lnA−lnB=lnBA before taking the limit. If an expression like sinb oscillates without approaching any value, the limit doesn't exist and the integral diverges.
Comparing with known integrals
Below a finite area
e−x2≤e−x,∫1∞e−xdx=e1
e−x2≤e−x∫1∞e−xdx=e1
Above an infinite area
x2+cosx≥x1,∫1∞xdx=∞
x2+cosx≥x1∫1∞xdx=∞
For positive functions, compare your function with a positive function whose integral you know. If your curve lies below a curve with finite area, its area is finite, so its integral converges. If your curve lies above a curve with infinite area, its area is infinite, so its integral diverges.
Being below a curve with infinite area or above a curve with finite area doesn't tell us whether our integral converges. To choose the right curve, look at which term dominates when x is large to guess whether the integral should converge or diverge.
8
Practice
Enter exact values, or "diverges" (or "infinite" for the volume problem). For the two comparison problems, enter "converges" or "diverges".
1
Evaluate ∫1∞x31dx, or show that it diverges.
Replace the infinite bound with b. What is ∫1bx−3dx?
If you got −21 Check the sign when integrating x−3. The power rule gives −2x−2=−2x21, not 2x21. Because x31 is positive on [1,∞), the integral can't be negative.
The upper bound is infinite, so replace ∞ with b and take the limit as b→∞.
∫1∞x3dx=b→∞lim∫1bx−3dx
Use the power rule to integrate x−3, and keep the minus sign.
∫1bx−3dx=[−2x21]1b=21−2b21
As b goes to infinity, 2b21 goes to 0, so the integral converges to 21.
b→∞lim(21−2b21)=21
2
Evaluate ∫044−xdx, or show that it diverges.
Where is 4−x1 undefined on [0,4]? Approach that bound from inside the interval.
If you got −4 Check the derivative of the inside term 4−x. The chain rule gives an extra factor of −1, so the antiderivative is −24−x, not 24−x.
Set up the limitThe denominator is 0 at x=4, so we approach 4 from the left to stay inside [0,4].
4−x=0atx=4:∫044−xdx=b→4−lim∫0b4−xdx
The derivative of 4−x is −1, so the chain rule gives an extra minus sign in the antiderivative.
∫0b(4−x)−21dx=[−24−x]0b=4−24−b
As b approaches 4 from the left, 4−b goes to 0, so the limit is 4.
b→4−lim(4−24−b)=4
3
Evaluate ∫0∞x1dx, or show that it diverges.
What are the two bad places in ∫0∞x1dx?
If you got 2 This is only the value of the piece from 0 to 1. Check whether the piece from 1 to ∞ converges.
Split the integralThere's a vertical asymptote at x=0 and an infinite upper bound, so we split at 1 to give each piece one bad place.
∫0∞xdx=∫01xdx+∫1∞xdx
For the piece on [0,1], the power of x is p=21<1, so this piece converges to 2.
∫01xdx=a→0+lim(2−2a)=2
For the tail on [1,∞), the power of x is p=21≤1, so this piece diverges to infinity. Because the tail diverges, the entire integral diverges.
∫1∞xdx=b→∞lim(2b−2)=∞
4
For which values of p does ∫01x2p1dx converge?
Which rule applies on [0,1]? What is the power of x?
If you got p>21 You used the tail rule for [1,∞), where 2p>1. On [0,1], the rule needs the power to be less than 1.
The case p>0When p>0, the denominator is 0 at x=0, so the integrand goes to infinity there, with power 2p. It converges only when 2p<1.
p>0:∫01x2pdx:2p<1→converges,2p≥1→diverges
When p≤0, the exponent −2p is greater than or equal to 0, so the function is continuous on [0,1] and the integral converges.
p≤0:x2p1=x−2p,−2p≥0
The condition 2p<1 gives p<21, which includes all values where p≤0.
p<21
5
Evaluate ∫0πsec2xdx, or show that it diverges.
Where is cosx=0 on the interval [0,π]?
If you got 0 You evaluated tanπ−tan0 straight across x=2π, but the function has a vertical asymptote there.
Find the vertical asymptoteBecause cos2π=0, the function sec2x has a vertical asymptote at x=2π, right inside [0,π].
sec2x=cos2x1,cos2π=0
Split the integral at the asymptote so each piece has only one bad place.
∫0πsec2xdx=∫02πsec2xdx+∫2ππsec2xdx
As b approaches 2π from the left, tanb goes to infinity. Since this piece diverges, the whole integral diverges.
∫02πsec2xdx=b→2π−lim(tanb−tan0)=∞
6
Evaluate ∫−∞∞xe−x2dx, or show that it diverges.
Split the integral at 0. What is ∫0∞xe−x2dx?
If you got diverges You may have treated this like ∫−∞∞xdx, which diverges. Check whether the two halves converge here.
Let u=x2, so du=2xdx, and integrate.
u=x2,du=2xdx:∫xe−x2dx=−21e−x2+C
For the right half, e−b2 approaches 0 as b→∞, so the limit is 21.
∫0∞xe−x2dx=b→∞lim(21−21e−b2)=21
For the left half, e−a2 approaches 0 as a→−∞, so the limit is −21.
∫−∞0xe−x2dx=a→−∞lim(−21+21e−a2)=−21
Both halves converge, so we add them to get 0.
∫−∞∞xe−x2dx=21+(−21)=0
7
Determine whether ∫1∞x+ex1dx converges or diverges.
When x is large, which term in x+ex grows faster?
If you got diverges Dropping ex shows that our function is smaller than x1. But ∫1∞x1dx is infinite, and being smaller than an infinite area gives no conclusion.
Compare with x1Dropping ex gives a larger function with infinite area, which gives no conclusion.
x+ex1<x1,∫1∞xdx=∞
Compare with e−xDropping x gives a larger function whose integral converges, so our integral converges too.
x+ex1<ex1=e−x,∫1∞e−xdx=e1
8
Determine whether ∫2∞lnx1dx converges or diverges.
For x≥2, is lnx smaller or larger than x?
If you got converges Having the function go to 0 as x goes to infinity isn't enough for the integral to converge. For example, x1 goes to 0, but its integral diverges.
For x≥2,lnx is smaller than x, so its reciprocal is larger than x1.
x≥2:lnx<x,lnx1>x1
The integral of x1 diverges to infinity, so our larger integral diverges too.
∫2∞xdx=b→∞lim(lnb−ln2)=∞
9
The region under y=x1 for x≥1 is rotated about the x-axis. Find the volume of the solid, or show that it is infinite. (Challenge)
Each slice is a disk with radius r=x1. What is the area of that disk?
If you got infinite The area of the region is infinite, but we use the square of the radius to find each disk's area. The disk area uses πr2=x2π, not xπ.
A slice at x is a disk with radius r=x1, so its area is πr2.
r=x1,πr2=π(x1)2=x2π
Integrate the disk areas from 1 to ∞.
V=π∫1∞x2dx=πb→∞lim(1−b1)=π
Even though the area under y=x1 is infinite, squaring the radius turns x1 into x21, and that makes the volume finite.