When two quantities change with time, an equation linking them also links their rates of change. If we know how fast one quantity is changing, we can find how fast the other is changing at that same moment.
Let's start with a 10-foot ladder leaning against a wall. The bottom slides away from the wall at 1 ft/s. How fast is the top sliding down when the bottom is 6 ft from the wall?
Let x be the distance from the wall to the bottom of the ladder, and let y be the distance from the ground to the top. Both change with time t, so we're given dtdx=1 and we want dtdy. The ladder's length never changes, so it stays the number 10 rather than a letter.
A 10-foot ladder slides down a wall
Text solution
An equation for every momentThe wall and the ground meet at a right angle, so the Pythagorean theorem holds the whole time the ladder slides.
x2+y2=102
Differentiate with respect to tBoth x and y depend on t, so each square gets the chain rule, and 102 is a constant.
2xdtdx+2ydtdy=0
Plug in this momentAt x=6, the Pythagorean equation gives y. Then the rates equation gives dtdy.
62+y2=102→y=8
2(6)(1)+2(8)dtdy=0
dtdy=−43ft/s
The new step here is taking the derivative with respect to time. It's the chain rule from implicit differentiation with t in place of x. Now x depends on t too, so x2 gets a rate of its own.
dxd(y2)=2ydxdy
dtd(x2)=2xdtdx,dtd(y2)=2ydtdy
dtd(x2)dtd(y2)=2xdtdx,=2ydtdy
The answer is negative because y is decreasing, so the top slides down at 43 ft/s. Any quantity that gets smaller over time has a negative rate. So if a tank's volume decreases at 2 ft3/min, then dtdV=−2 ft3/min.
2
Why the values go in after differentiating
We knew x=6 from the start, so why not plug it in before taking the derivative? Then y=8 is a constant, and its rate comes out 0, as if the ladder weren't sliding at all.
x=6 first:62+y2=102→y=8→2ydtdy=0→dtdy=0
x=6 first:62+y2=102→y=8→2ydtdy=0→dtdy=0
The relation x2+y2=102 holds the whole time the ladder moves, but x=6 is true at only one instant. The bottom also moves out at 1 ft/s the whole time, but solving for dtdy shows the top's speed depends on where the ladder is.
dtdy=−yxdtdx
x=6,y=8:dtdy=−43x=8,y=6:dtdy=−34
x=6,y=8:dtdyx=8,y=6:dtdy=−43=−34
At x=6 the top slides slower than the bottom moves, and at x=8 it slides faster. If a problem gives the moment as a time instead, say 3 seconds after the bottom was at x=3 ft, we find the position first, x=3+1(3)=6 ft, and then follow the same three steps.
Must the two ends of the ladder move at the same speed?
3
Walking away from a lamppost
A 6-foot person walks away from a 15-foot lamppost at 5 ft/s. How fast does the tip of their shadow move, and how fast does the shadow itself get longer, when the person is 10 feet from the post?
Let x be the person's distance from the lamppost, and let s be the length of the shadow. The shadow starts at the person's feet, so the tip is x+s from the post. That makes two different rates: the shadow gets longer at dtds, and the tip moves at dtd(x+s).
As with the ladder, we start from an equation that holds at every moment. This time it comes from the two similar right triangles in the picture, the big one under the lamp and the small one under the person.
Find how fast the tip of the shadow moves and how fast the shadow grows
Text solution
Similar trianglesThe big triangle has height 15 and base x+s, the small one height 6 and base s. They share the angle at the tip, so their ratios of height to base are equal.
x+s15=s6→9s=6x→s=32x
Write each length in x, then differentiateThe tip is at x+s=x+32x=35x, and dtdx=5.
dtds=32dtdx=310ft/s
dtd(x+s)=35dtdx=325ft/s
Where x=10 wentIt never came in. Both lengths are constant multiples of x, so both rates depend only on dtdx. And the tip moves at the person's speed plus the shadow's.
325=5+310
4
Getting rid of an extra rate
Water is pouring into a cone-shaped tank, point down, at 2 ft3/min. The tank has a top radius of 3 ft and a height of 6 ft. How fast is the water level rising when the water is 4 ft deep?
The water inside forms a smaller cone with radius r and height h, and both change as water pours in.
The volume of a cone is V=31πr2h. If we take the derivative with respect to t right away, the product rule gives two rates on the right side.
V=31πr2h→dtdV=31π(2rdtdrh+r2dtdh)
V=31πr2h→dtdV=31π(2rdtdrh+r2dtdh)
We know dtdV=2 and want dtdh, but nothing gives us dtdr, so one equation has two unknown rates. If this were a cylinder with both dtdr and dtdh given, the product rule would finish the problem, because dtdV would be the only unknown rate left. But here the water must fit the tank, so r and h change together.
So we write r in terms of h before taking the derivative. In the side view, the tank and the water form two similar right triangles, just as the lamppost and the person did.
hr=63→r=2h
h=4:r=2
Water pours into a cone tank of radius 3 ft and height 6 ft at 2 ft³/min. Find dh/dt when h = 4 ft.
Text solution
The volume in h aloneReplace r with 2h before differentiating, so no r is left.
V=31π(2h)2h=12πh3
Differentiate with respect to tNow dtdh is the only unknown rate.
dtdV=4πh2dtdh
Plug in this momentAt h=4 and dtdV=2:
2=4πdtdh→dtdh=2π1ft/min
What 4πh2 isIt's the area of the water's circular surface. The incoming water spreads over that surface, and as the surface widens, the level rises more slowly.
4πh2=π(2h)2=πr2
One equation can be solved for only one unknown rate. So every changing quantity in the equation needs a rate we're given or the rate we want.
5
Finding how fast an angle changes
A balloon rises straight up at 3 m/s from a spot on the ground 40 meters away from an observer. How fast is the angle of elevation, θ, increasing at the moment the balloon is 30 meters high?
The ground distance stays 40 meters, because neither the observer nor the launch spot moves. The height h changes at 3 m/s. The line of sight changes too, but we aren't given its rate, and we don't need to find it.
So we connect θ to h and the 40, and leave out the line of sight. Opposite over adjacent is tangent. Sine or cosine would bring in the line of sight, and with it a rate we don't have.
tanθ=40h
Find how fast the angle of elevation is increasing when the balloon is 30 m high
Text solution
Differentiate with respect to tThe derivative of tanθ is sec2θ, and the chain rule multiplies it by dtdθ.
sec2θdtdθ=401dtdh
Read secθ off the triangleWe don't need θ itself. At h=30 the legs are 30 and 40, so the line of sight is 50.
secθ=4050=45
sec2θ=1625
SolveWith dtdh=3:
1625dtdθ=403→dtdθ=1256rad/s
The rate comes out in radians per second because the derivative of tanθ is sec2θ only when θ is in radians. So if an angle's rate is given in revolutions per minute, multiply by 2π to turn it into radians per minute before you plug it in.
Which equation lets us find the angle’s rate directly?
Summary
The three steps
Every moment
x2+y2=102
Rates
2xdtdx+2ydtdy=0
This moment
x=6,y=8,dtdx=1:12+16dtdy=0
Write an equation that connects the quantities at every moment. Give a changing length a letter and a fixed length its number, like 10 for the ladder. Differentiate both sides with respect to time t, and only then plug in the values for the chosen moment. If a needed value isn't given at that moment, find it from the every-moment equation, like using 62+y2=102 to find y=8.
Why values go in last
x=6 first:62+y2=102→dtdy=0
A value like x=6 is true at only one moment. If you plug it in before taking the derivative, you treat x as a constant number for all time. That forces y to stay 8, and differentiating gives dtdy=0, as if the ladder weren't moving. Differentiate the every-moment equation first, so the rates stay in the equation.
Setting up the equation
Write the quantity the problem asks for in letters before choosing your equation. The shadow's length is s, but the tip's distance from the post is x+s. Every changing letter in your equation should have a rate you know or a rate you want. If an extra changing quantity appears, use a relation to substitute for it before differentiating. Use similar triangles to get a relation like s=32x or r=2h, use a given curve, or pick a trig ratio like tanθ=40h that leaves out the line of sight.
Differentiating with respect to time
dtd(x2)=2xdtdx
dtd(tanθ)=sec2θdtdθ
dtd(r2h)=2rdtdrh+r2dtdh
Because every changing variable is a function of time, differentiating with respect to t gives each variable its own rate, like dtdx or dtdθ. A product of two changing quantities, like r2h, needs the product rule. The trig derivative formulas we've learned use angles measured in radians. If a rate is given in revolutions per minute, multiply by 2π to convert it to radians per minute.
Decreasing quantities have negative rates
air let out at 100cm3/s:dtdV=−100
When a quantity decreases over time, its rate of change is negative. If air leaves a balloon at 100 cm3/s, write dtdV=−100. A negative answer means the quantity is decreasing, so dtdy=−43 ft/s means the top of the ladder is sliding down at 43 ft/s.
6
Practice
Give exact answers, with units. A decreasing quantity has a negative rate of change.
1
Air is let out of a spherical balloon at 100 cm³/s. How fast is the radius changing when the radius is 5 cm? (The volume of a sphere is V=34πr3.)
Air is leaving the balloon, so is dtdV positive or negative?
If you got π1 cm/s Check the sign of dtdV. The volume is decreasing, so its rate of change is negative.
Both V and r change with time, so differentiate both sides with respect to t.
V=34πr3→dtdV=4πr2dtdr
Air is leaving the balloon, so dtdV=−100.
dtdV=−100,r=5:−100=100πdtdr→dtdr=−π1cm/s
dtdV=−100,r=5:−100=100πdtdr→dtdr=−π1cm/s
2
Car A starts 12 mi north of a crossroads and drives south toward it at 30 mi/h. At the same time, car B leaves the crossroads and drives east at 40 mi/h. How fast is the distance between the cars changing 12 minutes later?
Car A travels south at 30 mi/h for 12 minutes, which is 0.2 hours. How far north of the crossroads is it then?
If you got 50 mi/h Check the sign of dtdy. Car A is driving toward the crossroads, so its distance y is decreasing.
If you got −30 mi/h The cars have been moving for 12 minutes. Find their positions at that moment instead of using where they started.
Find the positions at 12 minutesFirst convert 12 minutes to 0.2 hours, then find each car's distance from the crossroads and the distance z between them.
Differentiate the relationThe cars and the crossroads form a right triangle at every moment, so differentiate x2+y2=z2 with respect to t, then divide by 2.
x2+y2=z2→xdtdx+ydtdy=zdtdz
x2+y2=z2→xdtdx+ydtdy=zdtdz
Find dtdzCar B is driving east, so dtdx=40, but car A is driving toward the crossroads, so dtdy=−30.
8(40)+6(−30)=10dtdz→140=10dtdz→dtdz=14mi/h
8(40)+6(−30)=10dtdz→140=10dtdz→dtdz=14mi/h
3
The radius of a cylinder is increasing at 2 cm/s while its height is decreasing at 3 cm/s. How fast is the volume changing when the radius is 5 cm and the height is 10 cm?
Both r and h change with time, so what rule do we need to differentiate r2h?
If you got 200π cm³/s The height is also changing, so don't treat h as a constant.
If you got 275π cm³/s Check the sign of dtdh. The height is decreasing, so its rate is negative.
Both r and h are changing with time, so differentiate V=πr2h using the product rule.
V=πr2h→dtdV=π(2rdtdrh+r2dtdh)
V=πr2h→dtdV=π(2rdtdrh+r2dtdh)
The radius grows at 2 cm/s and the height shrinks at 3 cm/s, so dtdr=2 and dtdh=−3.
A trough is 10 ft long. Its ends are triangles, point down, 4 ft across the top and 2 ft deep. Water is pumped in at 12 ft³/min. (a) How fast is the water level rising when the water is 1.5 ft deep? (b) At that moment, how fast is the width of the water's surface increasing?
The triangular end has width 4 and depth 2, so what is the surface width w when the water depth is h?
If you got 58 ft/min Check the ratio of width to depth on the end triangle. The width is twice the depth, not half.
If you got 53 ft/min The surface width w changes as the trough fills, so it isn't always 4 ft.
Differentiate w=2h with respect to t.
Write the volume in terms of hUse similar triangles on the triangular end to write the surface width w as 2h, so the volume depends only on h.
hw=24→w=2h,V=21wh⋅10=10h2
hw=24→w=2h,V=21wh⋅10=10h2
Find how fast the water risesDifferentiate with respect to t, then plug in dtdV=12 and h=1.5.
dtdV=20hdtdh→12=30dtdh→dtdh=52ft/min
dtdV=20hdtdh→12=30dtdh→dtdh=52ft/min
At this depth the surface area of the water is 30 ft2, and dividing the incoming flow of 12 ft3/min by this area gives the same 52 ft/min.
h=1.5:w=3,surface area=3⋅10=30,3012=52
h=1.5:w=3,surface area=3⋅10=30,3012=52
Find how fast the surface width increasesDifferentiate w=2h with respect to t, and plug in dtdh=52.
w=2h→dtdw=2dtdh=2⋅52=54ft/min
5
A lighthouse is 1 km from the nearest point P on a straight shore, and its beam turns at 2 revolutions per minute. How fast is the spot of light moving along the shore when it is 1 km from P?
How many radians are in 2 full revolutions?
If you got 4 km/min Trig derivatives need angles in radians. Convert revolutions per minute to radians per minute first.
Let x be the distance along the shore from P to the spot of light, and let θ be the angle between the beam and the line from the lighthouse to P. In the right triangle with adjacent side 1, the opposite side is x, so tanθ=x.
tanθ=1x→sec2θdtdθ=dtdx
Convert to radiansEach revolution is 2π radians, so multiply 2 rev/min by 2π.
dtdθ=2⋅2π=4πrad/min
When x=1, the triangle has legs 1 and 1, so the hypotenuse is 2 and sec2θ=2.
x=1:secθ=12,sec2θ=2→dtdx=2⋅4π=8πkm/min
x=1:secθ=12,sec2θ=2→dtdx=2⋅4π=8πkm/min
6
Challenge. For the ladder on this page (10 ft long, its bottom moving away from the wall at a constant 1 ft/s), (a) find dt2d2y when the bottom is 6 ft from the wall. (b) At that moment, is the speed of the top of the ladder increasing or decreasing?
Use the product rule on both terms of xdtdx+ydtdy=0.
If you got −81 ft/s² Differentiating ydtdy needs the product rule. Don't leave out the (dtdy)2 term.If you got −1289 ft/s² Differentiating xdtdx needs the product rule. Don't leave out the (dtdx)2 term.
(b)
Both dtdy and dt2d2y are negative. Is the speed, which is dtdy, growing or shrinking?
Differentiate a second timeDifferentiating x2+y2=100 gives xdtdx+ydtdy=0. Each term is a product of functions of t, so use the product rule on each to differentiate again.
The bottom moves at a constant speed, so dt2d2x=0. From x2+y2=100,x=6 gives y=8, and 6(1)+8dtdy=0 gives dtdy=−43.
dtdx=1 at every t→dt2d2x=0;x=6,y=8,dtdy=−43
dtdx=1 at every t→dt2d2x=0;x=6,y=8,dtdy=−43
Plug in the values and solve for dt2d2y.
1+0+169+8dt2d2y=0→dt2d2y=−12825ft/s2
1+0+169+8dt2d2y=0→dt2d2y=−12825ft/s2
Is the top falling faster or slower?Because dtdy is negative and its derivative is also negative, dtdy is becoming more negative, so the downward speed dtdy is increasing.