Let's find the volume when the region under y=3x2−x3, from x=0 to x=3, is rotated about the y-axis.
y=3x2−x3,0≤x≤3about the y-axis:V=?
The curve meets the x-axis where 3x2−x3=0, which gives the region's two ends.
3x2−x3=x2(3−x)=0→x=0,x=3
Washers would need rectangles perpendicular to the y-axis, so horizontal ones. But both ends of a horizontal rectangle lie on this same curve, so finding its length means solving a cubic for x, which is not something we want to do.
3x2−x3=y→x=?
A vertical rectangle at x is much easier, because its height is just 3x2−x3. It runs parallel to the axis of rotation, so spinning it about the y-axis sweeps out a thin cylinder wall, called a shell. Cut the wall and flatten it, and it's a rectangle.
The flattened wall is 2πx long, the circumference of the circle the rectangle travels around, and 3x2−x3 high, and the rectangle's width gives it a thickness dx. So a shell has 2πx where a disk had πr2, because we use the wall, not the face.
Shell dimensions
radius=x
height=3x2−x3
thickness=dx
Volume of one shell
volume≈2πx⋅(3x2−x3)⋅dx
Total volume
V=∫032πx(3x2−x3)dx
More generally, for any region under y=f(x)≥0 from x=a to x=b where a≥0, rotating around the y-axis gives shells of radius x, height f(x), and thickness dx. Adding them up gives our volume formula.
V=∫ab2πxf(x)dx
Find the volume when the region under y=3x2−x3 for 0≤x≤3 is rotated about the y-axis
Text solution
Bounds from the regionEach shell already wraps all the way around the y-axis, so the shell at x=2 covers x=−2 too. The rectangles only cover the region, from 0 to 3.
V=∫032πx(3x2−x3)dx
Multiply out and integratePull the 2π out front and multiply the x through.
2π∫03(3x3−x4)dx=2π[43x4−5x5]03
=2π(4243−5243)=10243π
We can check the shell formula on a solid we already know. When the region between y=x2 and y=4 for 0≤x≤2 was spun about the y-axis, disks gave 8π. A vertical rectangle there has height 4−x2, and the shells give the same 8π.
V=2π∫02x(4−x2)dx=2π∫02(4x−x3)dx=2π(8−4)=8π
V=π∫04(y)2dy=π∫04ydy=8π
2
Finding the shell's radius
Now let's rotate the region under y=x2, from x=1 to x=2, around three different vertical lines.
y=x2,1≤x≤2about x=0,x=3,x=−1V=?
With washers about the y-axis, a horizontal rectangle's left end is on x=1 below y=1 and on x=y above it, so we'd need two integrals. A vertical rectangle has height x2 across the whole region, so shells need only one.
The radius of a shell is the distance from the axis of rotation to the rectangle. Here's that distance for the rectangle at x=1.5, and then for any x, with each of the three axes.
On either side, the radius is the larger x-value minus the smaller x-value.
Rotate the region under y=x2 from x=1 to x=2 about x=0,x=3, and x=−1
y=x2
1
2
x=0
x=3
x=−1
Text solution
About x=0The hole of radius 1 needs nothing subtracted. We only put shells where the region is, from x=1 to x=2.
V=2π∫12x⋅x2dx=2π[4x4]12=215π
About x=3The height stays x2 and x still runs from 1 to 2. Only the radius changes.
V=2π∫12(3−x)x2dx=2π∫12(3x2−x3)dx
=2π(7−415)=213π
About x=−1
V=2π∫12(x+1)x2dx=2π∫12(x3+x2)dx
=2π(415+37)=673π
Does a hole in the solid mean a shell needs two radii?
3
Shells about a horizontal axis
Let's find the volume when the region between y=x,y=2−x, and the x-axis is rotated about the x-axis.
y=x,y=2−x,y=0about the x-axis:V=?
Vertical rectangles would give disks, but their top changes curves at x=1, from y=x to y=2−x, so we'd need two integrals. A horizontal rectangle is parallel to the x-axis, so it sweeps out a shell, with thickness dy. To find its length, we need each curve as x in terms of y.
0.5
1.25
(1,1)
y=x
x=y2
y=2−x
x=2−y
2
x-axis
y=xy=2−x→x=y2→x=2−y
From y=0 up to y=1, where the curves meet, the left end stays on x=y2 and the right end on x=2−y. Neither end changes curves, so one integral will do.
Find the volume when the region bounded by y=x,y=2−x, and y=0 is rotated about the x-axis
y=x
y=2−x
x-axis
Text solution
One shellThe radius is the distance up from the x-axis to the rectangle, y, and the height is the rectangle's length, the right x minus the left x.
volume≈2πy⋅(2−y−y2)⋅dy
Add them up from y=0 to y=1
V=2π∫01y(2−y−y2)dy=2π∫01(2y−y2−y3)dy
=2π(1−31−41)=65π
About y=3 insteadThe length and the bounds stay the same. Only the radius changes, to the distance from y=3 down to the rectangle.
radius=3−y
4
Choosing between shells and washers
Now let's take the same region, between y=x,y=2−x, and the x-axis, and rotate it about the y-axis instead.
y=x,y=2−x,y=0about the y-axis:V=?
Vertical rectangles would sweep out shells about the y-axis, but their top changes curves at x=1, so that's two integrals again. A horizontal rectangle has one formula for its length across the whole region, 2−y−y2. This time it's perpendicular to the axis, so it sweeps out a washer.
2−y
y2
dy
y-axis
outer radiusinner radiusthickness=2−y=y2=dy
Find the volume when the region between y=x,y=2−x, and the x-axis is rotated about the y-axis
y=x
y=2−x
y-axis
Text solution
One washer integralThe outer radius reaches the line, 2−y, and the inner radius reaches the parabola, y2.
V=π∫01[(2−y)2−(y2)2]dy=π∫01(4−4y+y2−y4)dy
=π(4−2+31−51)=1532π
Shells agree, in two integralsVertical rectangles give the same volume, split at x=1.
V=2π∫01xxdx+2π∫12x(2−x)dx=1532π
So the rectangle comes from the region, not the axis. For y=3x2−x3, vertical rectangles had one formula, and a horizontal one meant solving a cubic, so shells were simpler there. Here, washers are simpler. If both rectangles give one formula, either method works.
Region
Axis
One length formula
Other rectangle
Sweeps
y=3x2−x3
y-axis
vertical:3x2−x3
horizontal: ends from3x2−x3=y
shell
y=x2,1≤x≤2
y-axis
vertical:x2
horizontal: left end x=1,then x=y
shell
y=x,y=2−x
x-axis
horizontal:2−y−y2
vertical: top x,then 2−x
shell
y=x,y=2−x
y-axis
horizontal:2−y−y2
vertical: top x,then 2−x
washer
Can the same rectangle give a shell about one axis and a washer about another?
Summary
The shell method about the y-axis
x
2πx
height
dx
One shell
one shell≈2π⋅radius⋅height⋅thickness
one shell≈2π⋅radius⋅height⋅thickness
Total volume
V=∫ab2πx(top−bottom)dx
A vertical rectangle parallel to the y-axis sweeps out a thin cylindrical shell. Unrolling the shell gives a wall of length 2πx, height top−bottom, and thickness dx. Each shell at radius x already goes all the way around the axis, so integrate only across the region's x-values, from a to b.
Finding the radius
x
3−x
x+1
x=−1
x=0
x=3
1
2
x
y=x2
x=0:x=3:x=−1:x-axis:x3−xx+1y
The radius is just the distance from the axis to your rectangle. When the axis is vertical, take the larger x-value minus the smaller one. Rotating about x=3 gives 3−x, and rotating about x=−1 gives x+1. Moving a vertical axis changes only this radius. When the region doesn't intersect the axis, the solid has a hole in the center. We don't subtract an inner radius, because we only add shells from rectangles in the region.
Shells about a horizontal axis
V=∫cd2πy(right−left)dy
When rotating about a horizontal axis, take a horizontal rectangle parallel to the axis, with thickness dy. Rewrite each curve as x in terms of y, so the rectangle's length is right−left. For rotation about the x-axis, the radius is y, the distance from the x-axis up to the rectangle. Integrate with respect to y from the bottom of the region, c, to the top, d.
Choosing shells or washers
rectangle∥axisrectangle⊥axis→shell→disk or washer
rectangle∥axis→shellrectangle⊥axis→disk or washer
y=x,y=2−x:horizontalx-axis→shell,y-axis→washer
y=x,y=2−x:horizontalx-axis→shelly-axis→washer
Pick the rectangle from the region first, not the axis. Choose the rectangle whose ends stay on the same two curves across the entire region, so its length has one formula. Then check the axis of rotation to see what solid that rectangle sweeps out. A rectangle parallel to the axis sweeps out a shell, and a rectangle perpendicular to the axis sweeps out a disk or washer. For the region between y=x,y=2−x, and the x-axis, a horizontal rectangle goes from x=y2 to x=2−y with length 2−y−y2 for 0≤y≤1. Rotating it about the x-axis gives shells, and rotating about the y-axis gives washers. If both directions give one formula, either method works and gives the same volume.
5
Practice
Give exact values in terms of π.
1
Find the volume of the solid obtained by rotating the region bounded by y=4x−x2 and the x-axis about the y-axis.
When a vertical rectangle at x is rotated about the y-axis, what shape does it sweep out, and what is its radius?
Multiply the terms out before integrating. What is x(4x−x2)?
If you got 364π Check the constant out front. An unrolled shell of radius x has length 2πx, not πx.
Find the boundsSet 4x−x2=0 to find where the parabola intersects the x-axis.
4x−x2=x(4−x)=0→x=0,x=4
Set up the shell integralRotating a vertical rectangle at x about the y-axis gives a cylindrical shell with radius x and height 4x−x2.
V=2π∫04x(4x−x2)dx
Multiply x into the parentheses, then integrate term by term.
Find the volume of the solid obtained by rotating the region between x=y2 and x=y+2 about the line y=3.
The rotation axis y=3 is horizontal. Does a horizontal rectangle or a vertical rectangle sweep out a shell?
Set y2=y+2 to find the bounds in y.
The axis y=3 is above the region. What is the distance from a rectangle at height y up to y=3?
If you got 344π Check the lower bound. The region extends below the x-axis, so integrate from y=−1, not y=0.If you got 263π Check the radius. The axis y=3 is above the rectangle at height y, so the distance is 3−y, not y+3.
Find the bounds in ySet the two equations equal to find the y-values where the curves intersect.
y2=y+2→(y−2)(y+1)=0→y=−1,y=2
Find the length of the rectangleAt y=0, the line is to the right of the parabola, so subtract left from right.
y=0:x=0 on x=y2,x=2 on x=y+2→length (y+2)−y2
Find the radiusThe axis y=3 is above the whole region, so the radius is the distance from y up to 3.
radius=3−y
Multiply the radius by the length, then integrate with respect to y from −1 to 2.
Find the volume of the solid obtained by rotating the triangle with vertices (0,0),(1,1) and (2,0) about the y-axis.
If you draw a vertical rectangle at x=1.5, what equation gives its top? What equations give the left and right ends of a horizontal rectangle at height y?
A horizontal rectangle is perpendicular to the y-axis. What shape does it sweep out?
If you got 316π For x between 1 and 2, the top edge is y=2−x, not y=x.
Choose the rectangleVertical rectangles require two integrals because the top edge changes, but a horizontal rectangle runs from x=y to x=2−y all the way from y=0 to y=1.
vertical: top y=x for 0≤x≤1,y=2−x for 1≤x≤2horizontal: x=y to x=2−y,0≤y≤1
Find the radii of the washerA horizontal rectangle is perpendicular to the y-axis, so rotating it sweeps out a washer.
outer radius 2−y,inner radius y
Subtract the inner circle area from the outer circle area, then integrate.
V=π∫01[(2−y)2−(y)2]dy=π∫01(4−4y)dy=π(4−2)=2π
6
A hole of radius 1 is drilled through the center of a sphere of radius 2, along a diameter. Find the volume that remains. (Challenge)
Rotating the region inside the circle x2+y2=4 about the y-axis makes a sphere of radius 2. What range of x is left after drilling a hole of radius 1?
A vertical rectangle at x goes from the bottom of the circle, y=−4−x2, to the top, y=4−x2. What is its total height?
If you got 23π Check the height of the rectangle. The rectangle runs from y=−4−x2 up to y=4−x2, so its height is 24−x2.If you got 332π That's the volume of the entire sphere. The hole removes the part from x=0 to x=1.
Set up the regionThe sphere comes from rotating the region inside the circle x2+y2=4 about the y-axis, and after removing the hole of radius 1, we use the part of that region where x runs from 1 to 2.
x2+y2≤4,1≤x≤2,about the y-axis
Set up the shell integralThe vertical rectangle extends from the bottom of the circle to the top, so its height is 24−x2.
heightV=4−x2−(−4−x2)=24−x2=2π∫12x⋅24−x2dx
Substitute u=4−x2The derivative of 4−x2 is −2x, so substitute u=4−x2 and change the bounds.
udu=4−x2,=−2xdx,x=1x=2→u=3→u=0
Use the minus sign from du to reverse the bounds so they run from 0 to 3, then integrate u.