Calculus3Applications of Integration2 of 6
Applications of Integration · 2

Surface Area of Revolution

1

The surface area of a cone

When we rotate the line y=34xy = \frac34 x from x=0x = \run{0} to x=4x = \run{4} around the x-axis, we get the slanted outside of a cone. The flat circle at x=4x = 4 isn't part of it. Let's find this surface area, SS.

For volume, we sliced the solid into thin disks of area πr2\rad{\pi r^2} and thickness dx\run{dx}. For the surface, we take one thin band around the cone at xx. Its radius is 34x\rad{\frac34 x}, so the distance around it is 2π(34x)\rad{2\pi\left(\frac34 x\right)}.

?\htmlClass{lc-pink}{?}
2π(34x)\htmlClass{lc-green}{2\pi\big(\tfrac34x\big)}

Cut and unrolled, the band is almost a rectangle of length 2π(34x)\rad{2\pi\left(\frac34 x\right)}. But its width isn't dx\run{dx}. Look at the cone cut in half from the side: the disk's rim is parallel to the x-axis, but the band lies along the slanted line, so while it runs dx\run{dx} it also rises dy\rise{dy}.

The disk's rim has width dx\run{dx}, while the band along the surface has width ds\wd{ds}.
Find the surface area when y=34xy = \frac34 x from x=0x = \run{0} to x=4x = \run{4} is rotated about the x-axis
Text solution
The width of a bandFrom arc length, ds\wd{ds} is the hypotenuse of the triangle with legs dx\run{dx} and dy\rise{dy}, and the slope is 34\rise{\frac34}. The sides are in the ratio 4:3:5\run{4} : \rise{3} : \wd{5}.
ds\displaystyle \wd{ds} =1+(34)2 dx\displaystyle = \wd{\sqrt{1 + \Big(\frac34\Big)^2}}\,\run{dx} =54 dx\displaystyle = \wd{\frac54}\,\run{dx}
Add up the bandsEach band's area is its circumference times its width.
S\displaystyle S =∫042π(34x) 54 dx\displaystyle = \int_{\run{0}}^{\run{4}} \rad{2\pi\Big(\frac34 x\Big)}\,\wd{\frac54}\,\run{dx} =15π8∫04x dx\displaystyle = \frac{15\pi}{8}\int_{\run{0}}^{\run{4}} x\,\run{dx} =15π\displaystyle = 15\pi
S=∫042π(34x) 54 dx=15π8∫04x dx=15π\displaystyle \begin{aligned}S &= \int_{\run{0}}^{\run{4}} \rad{2\pi\Big(\frac34 x\Big)}\,\wd{\frac54}\,\run{dx}\\[4pt] &= \frac{15\pi}{8}\int_{\run{0}}^{\run{4}} x\,\run{dx} = 15\pi\end{aligned}
Why not dx\run{dx}?With dx\run{dx} in place of ds\wd{ds}, we'd add up cylinder walls parallel to the x-axis. However thin they get, they never lie along the slanted surface, and their area is 12π12\pi, only 45\frac45 of SS.

For a curve y=f(x)y = f(x) on or above the x-axis, the slope f′(x)\rise{f'(x)} can change from point to point, but the width of the band at xx is always ds=1+f′(x)2 dx\wd{ds} = \wd{\sqrt{1 + f'(x)^2}}\,\run{dx}.

band at x:2πf(x) ds\displaystyle \text{band at } x\text{:} \quad \rad{2\pi f(x)}\,\wd{ds}
ds\displaystyle \wd{ds} =1+f′(x)2 dx\displaystyle = \wd{\sqrt{1 + f'(x)^2}}\,\run{dx}
S\displaystyle S =∫ab2πf(x) 1+f′(x)2 dx\displaystyle = \int_{\run{a}}^{\run{b}} \rad{2\pi f(x)}\,\wd{\sqrt{1 + f'(x)^2}}\,\run{dx}

Next to volume, the circle's area πf(x)2\rad{\pi f(x)^2} becomes its circumference 2πf(x)\rad{2\pi f(x)}, and the thickness dx\run{dx} becomes the slanted width ds\wd{ds}.

Volume
V\displaystyle V =∫abπf(x)2 dx\displaystyle = \int_{\run{a}}^{\run{b}} \rad{\pi f(x)^2}\,\run{dx}
Surface area
S\displaystyle S =∫ab2πf(x) ds\displaystyle = \int_{\run{a}}^{\run{b}} \rad{2\pi f(x)}\,\wd{ds}

We can also see it from arc length: each tiny piece ds\wd{ds} of the curve travels around a circle of circumference 2πf(x)\rad{2\pi f(x)}, so we multiply each ds\wd{ds} by that circumference.

Will thinner cylinder walls give us the correct surface area?

2

Checking the formula on a sphere

Let's test the formula on a surface whose area we already know. Rotating the top half of the circle y=4−x2y = \sqrt{4 - x^2} from x=−2x = \run{-2} to x=2x = \run{2} about the x-axis gives a sphere of radius 2\rad{2}, and from geometry its surface area is 4π⋅22=16π4\pi \cdot 2^2 = 16\pi. Does the integral agree?

Find the surface area of a sphere of radius 2\rad{2}
Text solution
The square root in ds\wd{ds}Writing 11 as 4−x24−x2\frac{4 - x^2}{4 - x^2} combines 1+f′(x)21 + \rise{f'(x)^2} into one fraction.
f′(x)\displaystyle \rise{f'(x)} =−x4−x2\displaystyle = \rise{-\frac{x}{\sqrt{4 - x^2}}}
1+f′(x)2\displaystyle \wd{1 + f'(x)^2} =44−x2\displaystyle = \wd{\frac{4}{4 - x^2}}
1+f′(x)2\displaystyle \wd{\sqrt{1 + f'(x)^2}} =24−x2\displaystyle = \frac{\wd{2}}{\rad{\sqrt{4 - x^2}}}
Multiply in the radiusThe radius cancels the root before we integrate.
4−x2⋅24−x2\displaystyle \rad{\sqrt{4 - x^2}}\cdot\frac{\wd{2}}{\rad{\sqrt{4 - x^2}}} =2\displaystyle = 2
IntegrateNo xx is left inside, so the integral matches geometry.
S\displaystyle S =∫−222π⋅2 dx\displaystyle = \int_{\run{-2}}^{\run{2}} 2\pi\cdot 2\,\run{dx} =16π\displaystyle = 16\pi =4π⋅22\displaystyle = 4\pi\cdot 2^2

Why does the root cancel? Compare two bands with the same run dx\run{dx}. At x=3x = \sqrt3, the radius is half what it is at x=0x = 0, but the surface slants more, so the width along the curve doubles. Every band on the sphere has the same area.

x=0:2π⋅2⋅dx=4π dxx=3:2π⋅1⋅2 dx=4π dx\displaystyle \begin{aligned}x = 0\text{:}&\quad 2\pi\cdot\rad{2}\cdot\run{dx} = 4\pi\,\run{dx}\\[8pt] x = \sqrt3\text{:}&\quad 2\pi\cdot\rad{1}\cdot\wd{2}\,\run{dx} = 4\pi\,\run{dx}\end{aligned}

Multiplying the radius into the square root helps on other curves too. For y=xy = \sqrt{x}, the derivative squared is f′(x)2=14x\rise{f'(x)^2} = \rise{\frac{1}{4x}}. Bringing the radius x\rad{\sqrt{x}} inside the square root turns two separate roots into one root, x+14\sqrt{x + \frac14}.

y=x:x⋅1+14x\displaystyle {y = \sqrt{x}}\text{:} \quad \rad{\sqrt{x}}\cdot\wd{\sqrt{1 + \frac{1}{4x}}} =x+14\displaystyle = \sqrt{x + \frac14}
3

Rotating about the y-axis

Now let's rotate y=x2y = x^2, from x=0x = \run{0} to x=2x = \run{\sqrt2}, about the y-axis instead. That sweeps out a dish, and we want its surface area.

A point (x,x2)(x, x^2) on the curve now circles the y-axis, so its radius is the horizontal distance across to that axis, x\rad{x}. About the x-axis, the same point's radius would be x2\rad{x^2}.

Find the surface area when y=x2y = x^2, from x=0x = \run{0} to x=2x = \run{\sqrt2}, is rotated about the y-axis
Text solution
Radius and ds\wd{ds}The radius is x\rad{x}. The curve hasn't changed, so ds\wd{ds} stays in dx\run{dx}, even though we turn about the y-axis.
radius\displaystyle \text{radius} =x\displaystyle = \rad{x}
ds\displaystyle \wd{ds} =1+4x2 dx\displaystyle = \wd{\sqrt{1 + 4x^2}}\,\run{dx}
S\displaystyle S =∫022πx 1+4x2 dx\displaystyle = \int_{\run{0}}^{\run{\sqrt2}} \rad{2\pi x}\,\wd{\sqrt{1 + 4x^2}}\,\run{dx}
SubstituteThe x\rad{x} from the radius is what dudu needs.
u=1+4x2u = 1 + 4x^2du=8x dxdu = 8\rad{x}\,\run{dx}x=0→u=1x = \run{0} \to u = 1x=2→u=9x = \run{\sqrt2} \to u = 9
S\displaystyle S =2π8∫19u du\displaystyle = \frac{2\pi}{8}\int_1^9 \sqrt{u}\,du =π6(27−1)\displaystyle = \frac{\pi}{6}(27 - 1) =13π3\displaystyle = \frac{13\pi}{3}

About another horizontal line, like y=−1y = \ax{-1}, the curve and its ds\wd{ds} stay the same. Only the radius changes, to the distance from (x,x2)(x, x^2) down to that line.

(x, x2)(x,\,x^2)
x2+1\htmlClass{lc-green}{x^2+1}
y=−1\htmlClass{lc-orange}{y=-1}
radius\displaystyle \text{radius} =x2−(−1)\displaystyle = x^2 - (\ax{-1}) =x2+1\displaystyle = \rad{x^2 + 1}
ds\displaystyle \wd{ds} =1+4x2 dx\displaystyle = \wd{\sqrt{1 + 4x^2}}\,\run{dx}

Which part of the surface-area formula changes with the axis?

4

Choosing x\run{x} or y\rise{y} for ds\wd{ds}

Next, let's rotate y=x3y = \sqrt[3]{x}, from x=0x = \run{0} to x=1x = \run{1}, about the y-axis. This time, writing ds\wd{ds} in dx\run{dx} puts xx in a denominator under the root. Remember from arc length that we can factor dy\rise{dy} out of dx2+dy2\wd{\sqrt{\run{dx^2} + \rise{dy^2}}} instead.

ds\displaystyle \wd{ds} =dx2+dy2\displaystyle = \wd{\sqrt{\run{dx^2} + \rise{dy^2}}} =1+(dxdy)2 dy\displaystyle = \wd{\sqrt{1 + \Big(\frac{dx}{dy}\Big)^2}}\,\rise{dy}
Find the surface area when y=x3y = \sqrt[3]{x}, from x=0x = \run{0} to x=1x = \run{1}, is rotated about the y-axis
Text solution
Write ds\wd{ds} in y\rise{y}In x\run{x}, the root has a fraction that's undefined at x=0x = 0. From x=y3x = y^3, the root in y\rise{y} has no fraction at all.
ds\displaystyle \wd{ds} =1+19x43 dx\displaystyle = \wd{\sqrt{1 + \frac{1}{9x^{\frac43}}}}\,\run{dx}
ds\displaystyle \wd{ds} =1+9y4 dy\displaystyle = \wd{\sqrt{1 + 9y^4}}\,\rise{dy}
SubstituteIn y\rise{y}, the radius is y3\rad{y^3} and yy runs from 0\rise{0} to 1\rise{1}. The y3\rad{y^3} outside the root is what dudu needs.
u=1+9y4u = 1 + 9y^4du=36y3 dydu = 36\rad{y^3}\,\rise{dy}y=0→u=1y = \rise{0} \to u = 1y=1→u=10y = \rise{1} \to u = 10
S\displaystyle S =2π36∫110u du\displaystyle = \frac{2\pi}{36}\int_1^{10}\sqrt{u}\,du =π27(1010−1)\displaystyle = \frac{\pi}{27}\Big(10\sqrt{10} - 1\Big)

Integrating in x\run{x} would give the same surface area, but the root is much simpler in y\rise{y}. Once we pick y\rise{y}, the radius and the bounds go in y\rise{y} too.

y3\htmlClass{lc-green}{y^3}
(y3, y)(y^3,\,y)
1\htmlClass{lc-violet}{1}
0\htmlClass{lc-violet}{0}
y\htmlClass{lc-orange}{y}
xx
radius\displaystyle \text{radius} =x\displaystyle = \rad{x} =y3\displaystyle = \rad{y^3}
0≤y≤1\displaystyle {\rise{0} \le y \le \rise{1}}
S\displaystyle S =∫012πy3 1+9y4 dy\displaystyle = \int_{\rise{0}}^{\rise{1}} \rad{2\pi y^3}\,\wd{\sqrt{1 + 9y^4}}\,\rise{dy}

Summary

From volume to surface area
Volume
V=∫πr2 dxV = \int \rad{\pi r^2}\,\run{dx}
Surface area
S=∫2πr dsS = \int \rad{2\pi r}\,\wd{ds}

To find volume, we add up the volumes of disks with face area πr2\rad{\pi r^2} and thickness dx\run{dx}. Surface area adds up the thin bands around the outside, so the circle's area becomes its circumference 2πr\rad{2\pi r}, and the flat thickness dx\run{dx} becomes the slanted width ds\wd{ds} along the curve.

The band width ds\wd{ds}
In x\run{x}
ds=1+(dydx)2 dx\wd{ds} = \wd{\sqrt{1 + \Big(\dfrac{dy}{dx}\Big)^2}}\,\run{dx}
In y\rise{y}
ds=1+(dxdy)2 dy\wd{ds} = \wd{\sqrt{1 + \Big(\dfrac{dx}{dy}\Big)^2}}\,\rise{dy}

A band lies on the slanted surface, so its width is a piece of arc length ds\wd{ds}, not dx\run{dx}. Using dx\run{dx} instead of the length along the curve for the band's width adds up flat cylinder walls parallel to the axis, and that doesn't give the slanted surface area.

Finding the radius
x\htmlClass{lc-green}{x}
x2\htmlClass{lc-green}{x^2}
x2+1\htmlClass{lc-green}{x^2+1}
x\htmlClass{lc-orange}{x}
y\htmlClass{lc-orange}{y}
y=−1\htmlClass{lc-orange}{y=-1}

The radius r\rad{r} is always the distance from the point on the curve to the axis you rotate around. For y=x2y = x^2, that's x2\rad{x^2} for the x-axis, x\rad{x} for the y-axis, and x2+1\rad{x^2 + 1} for the line y=−1y = \ax{-1}. The axis sets the radius, but ds\wd{ds} belongs to the curve itself, so ds\wd{ds} stays the same for every axis.

Choosing dx\run{dx} or dy\rise{dy}
y\displaystyle y =x3  →  x\displaystyle = \sqrt[3]{x} \;\to\; x =y3\displaystyle = y^3
ds\displaystyle \wd{ds} =1+9y4 dy\displaystyle = \wd{\sqrt{1 + 9y^4}}\,\rise{dy}
r=y3,0≤y≤1\displaystyle {\rad{r} = \rad{y^3}}, \qquad {\rise{0} \le y \le \rise{1}}

Choose dx\run{dx} or dy\rise{dy} for ds\wd{ds} based on which derivative gives a simpler square root, not which axis the curve rotates around. For y=x3y = \sqrt[3]{x}, solving for x=y3x = y^3 gives a polynomial under the square root instead of a fraction. Once ds\wd{ds} is in y\rise{y}, write the radius r\rad{r} and the bounds in y\rise{y} too.

Simplifying before integrating
4−x2⋅24−x2\displaystyle \rad{\sqrt{4 - x^2}}\cdot\frac{\wd{2}}{\rad{\sqrt{4 - x^2}}} =2\displaystyle = 2
x⋅1+14x\displaystyle \rad{\sqrt{x}}\cdot\wd{\sqrt{1 + \frac{1}{4x}}} =x+14\displaystyle = \sqrt{x + \frac14}
x 1+4x2 dx:\rad{x}\,\wd{\sqrt{1 + 4x^2}}\,\run{dx}\text{:}u=1+4x2,u = 1 + 4x^2,x dx=du8\rad{x}\,\run{dx} = \dfrac{du}{8}

Before integrating, multiply the radius into the square root. For a sphere, the square root in the radius cancels the square root in the denominator completely. For y=xy = \sqrt{x}, bringing the radius inside leaves a single square root. In an expression like x 1+4x2\rad{x}\,\wd{\sqrt{1 + 4x^2}}, the factor outside the square root can give us the x dx\rad{x}\,\run{dx} needed for substitution.

5

Practice

Enter exact values using fractions and π\pi where needed.

1
Find the area of the surface obtained by rotating the curve y=2xy = 2\sqrt{x}, 0≤x≤30 \le x \le 3, about the xx-axis.

Surface area uses bands of width ds=1+f′(x)2 dxds = \sqrt{1 + f'(x)^2}\,dx. What is f′(x)f'(x) for y=2xy = 2\sqrt{x}?

When you multiply the radius 2x2\sqrt{x} into 1+1x\sqrt{1 + \frac1x}, what is x(1+1x)x\left(1 + \frac1x\right)?

Slant widthFind the derivative f′(x)\rise{f'(x)} to set up ds=1+f′(x)2 dx\wd{ds} = \wd{\sqrt{1 + f'(x)^2}}\,\run{dx}.
f′(x)=1x1+f′(x)2=1+1x\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\rise{f'(x)} &= \rise{\frac{1}{\sqrt x}}\\ \wd{1 + f'(x)^2} &= \wd{1 + \frac1x}\end{aligned}
Combine the rootsThe radius about the x-axis is y=2xy = \rad{2\sqrt{x}}, and multiplying it into the square root clears the fraction.
2x⋅1+1x\displaystyle \rad{2\sqrt{x}}\cdot\wd{\sqrt{1 + \frac1x}} =2x+1\displaystyle = 2\sqrt{x + 1}
IntegrateNow integrate from x=0x = \run{0} to x=3x = \run{3}.
S\displaystyle S =∫032π⋅2x+1 dx\displaystyle = \int_{\run{0}}^{\run{3}} 2\pi\cdot 2\sqrt{x+1}\,\run{dx} =4π⋅23[(x+1)32]03\displaystyle = 4\pi\cdot\frac23\Big[(x+1)^{\frac32}\Big]_0^3 =8π3(8−1)\displaystyle = \frac{8\pi}{3}(8 - 1) =56π3\displaystyle = \frac{56\pi}{3}
2
Which integral gives the area of the surface obtained by rotating the curve y=exy = e^x, 0≤x≤10 \le x \le 1, about the yy-axis?

The curve rotates about the y-axis. What is the distance from a point (x,ex)(x, e^x) to the y-axis?

If you got (B) Check the radius. The distance from (x,ex)(x, e^x) to the y-axis is xx, not exe^x.

If you got (C) Check the square of the derivative. (ex)2(e^x)^2 is e2xe^{2x}, not exe^x.

If you got (D) Check the bounds. The integral is in dxdx, so the bounds are the x-values 00 to 11, not the y-values.

RadiusThe distance from a point on the curve to the y-axis is its x-coordinate.
radius\displaystyle \text{radius} =x\displaystyle = \rad{x}
Slant widthThe derivative of exe^x is ex\rise{e^x}, and squaring it gives e2xe^{2x}.
y′=exds=1+(ex)2 dx=1+e2x dx\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\rise{y'} &= \rise{e^x}\\ \wd{ds} &= \wd{\sqrt{1 + (e^x)^2}}\,\run{dx} = \wd{\sqrt{1 + e^{2x}}}\,\run{dx}\end{aligned}
Set up the integralPutting the radius, slant width, and bounds into ∫2πr ds\int \rad{2\pi r}\,\wd{ds} gives option A.
S\displaystyle S =2π∫01x 1+e2x dx(A)\displaystyle = 2\pi\int_{\run{0}}^{\run{1}} \rad{x}\,\wd{\sqrt{1 + e^{2x}}}\,\run{dx} \qquad \text{(A)}
3
Find the area of the surface obtained by rotating the line y=xy = x, 0≤x≤20 \le x \le 2, about the line y=−1y = -1.

What is the vertical distance from a point (x,x)(x, x) on the line down to y=−1y = -1?

RadiusThe radius is the vertical distance from the line y=xy = x down to y=−1y = \ax{-1}.
radius\displaystyle \text{radius} =x−(−1)\displaystyle = x - (\ax{-1}) =x+1\displaystyle = \rad{x + 1}
Slant widthThe derivative of xx is 1\rise{1}, so 1+(y′)2\wd{1 + (y')^2} is constant.
y′=1ds=1+1 dx=2 dx\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\rise{y'} &= \rise{1}\\ \wd{ds} &= \wd{\sqrt{1 + 1}}\,\run{dx} = \wd{\sqrt2}\,\run{dx}\end{aligned}
IntegratePull the constants out front, then integrate x+1\rad{x + 1} from 0\run{0} to 2\run{2}.
S\displaystyle S =∫022π(x+1) 2 dx\displaystyle = \int_{\run{0}}^{\run{2}} \rad{2\pi(x + 1)}\,\wd{\sqrt2}\,\run{dx} =22 π[x22+x]02\displaystyle = 2\sqrt2\,\pi\Big[\frac{x^2}{2} + x\Big]_0^2 =22 π⋅4\displaystyle = 2\sqrt2\,\pi\cdot 4 =82 π\displaystyle = 8\sqrt2\,\pi
4
Find the area of the surface obtained by rotating the circle x2+(y−3)2=1x^2 + (y - 3)^2 = 1 about the xx-axis.

Solve the circle equation for yy to find the equations for the top and bottom halves.

What is dsds for each half, and what radius do we use for each half when we rotate about the x-axis?

Split the circleSolve for yy to get the top and bottom halves of the circle.
y=3+1−x2y=3−1−x2\displaystyle \begin{aligned}y &= \rad{3 + \sqrt{1 - x^2}}\\ y &= \rad{3 - \sqrt{1 - x^2}}\end{aligned}
−1\displaystyle \run{-1} ≤x\displaystyle \le x ≤1\displaystyle \le \run{1}
Slant widthBoth halves have the same slope squared, so they share the same ds\wd{ds}.
y′=∓x1−x21+y′2=11−x2ds=dx1−x2\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\rise{y'} &= \rise{\mp\frac{x}{\sqrt{1 - x^2}}}\\ \wd{1 + y'^2} &= \wd{\frac{1}{1 - x^2}}\\ \wd{ds} &= \frac{\run{dx}}{\wd{\sqrt{1 - x^2}}}\end{aligned}
Surface area of both halvesThe top radius is 3+1−x2\rad{3 + \sqrt{1 - x^2}} and the bottom radius is 3−1−x2\rad{3 - \sqrt{1 - x^2}}.
top: 2π∫−11(31−x2+1)dx\displaystyle \text{top: } 2\pi\int_{\run{-1}}^{\run{1}}\Big(\frac{3}{\sqrt{1 - x^2}} + 1\Big)\run{dx}
bottom: 2π∫−11(31−x2−1)dx\displaystyle \text{bottom: } 2\pi\int_{\run{-1}}^{\run{1}}\Big(\frac{3}{\sqrt{1 - x^2}} - 1\Big)\run{dx}
Add and integrateWhen we add the two surface areas, the +1+1 and −1-1 terms cancel, so we just integrate 66 over the square root.
S\displaystyle S =2π∫−1161−x2 dx\displaystyle = 2\pi\int_{\run{-1}}^{\run{1}}\frac{6}{\sqrt{1 - x^2}}\,\run{dx} =12π[arcsin⁡x]−11\displaystyle = 12\pi\Big[\arcsin x\Big]_{-1}^{1} =12π⋅π\displaystyle = 12\pi\cdot\pi =12π2\displaystyle = 12\pi^2
5
The curve y=1xy = \dfrac1x, x≥1x \ge 1, is rotated about the xx-axis. Show that the surface has infinite area. (Challenge)

The square root 1+1x4\sqrt{1 + \frac{1}{x^4}} is at least 11. What happens to ∫1∞2πx dx\int_1^\infty \frac{2\pi}{x}\,dx?

If you got a finite area Check the comparison. Even though 1x\frac{1}{x} goes to 00, the integral ∫1∞1x dx\int_1^\infty \frac{1}{x}\,dx diverges to infinity.

Set up the integralThe radius about the x-axis is 1x\rad{\frac1x}, and the derivative is −1x2\rise{-\frac{1}{x^2}}.
y′=−1x2S=2π∫1∞1x 1+1x4 dx\displaystyle \begin{aligned}\rise{y'} &= \rise{-\frac{1}{x^2}}\\ S &= 2\pi\int_{\run{1}}^{\run{\infty}} \rad{\frac1x}\,\wd{\sqrt{1 + \frac{1}{x^4}}}\,\run{dx}\end{aligned}
Compare with 2π/xThe square root is always at least 11, so 2πx\frac{2\pi}{x} times the square root is at least 2πx\frac{2\pi}{x}.
1+1x4\displaystyle \wd{\sqrt{1 + \frac{1}{x^4}}} ≥1\displaystyle \ge 1
2πx 1+1x4\displaystyle \frac{2\pi}{x}\,\wd{\sqrt{1 + \frac{1}{x^4}}} ≥2πx\displaystyle \ge \frac{2\pi}{x}
Evaluate the smaller integralThe integral of 2πx\frac{2\pi}{x} diverges to infinity, so the larger surface area integral must diverge too.
∫1b2πx dx\displaystyle \int_{\run{1}}^{\run{b}} \frac{2\pi}{x}\,\run{dx} =2πln⁡b→∞ as b→∞\displaystyle = 2\pi\ln b \to \infty \text{ as } b \to \infty
S\displaystyle S =∞\displaystyle = \infty
Compare with volumeThe volume of the same solid is finite, even though its surface area is infinite.
V\displaystyle V =π∫1∞1x2 dx\displaystyle = \pi\int_{\run{1}}^{\run{\infty}} \rad{\frac{1}{x^2}}\,\run{dx} =π\displaystyle = \pi