With the disk method, each rectangle stood on the axis of rotation and swept out a solid disk of volume π(radius)2dx. But what happens if a rectangle doesn't reach the axis? Let's find the volume when the region between y=2x and y=x2 turns about the x-axis.
x-axis:V=?
The curves meet at x=0 and x=2. A thin rectangle at x=1 runs from the parabola at y=1 up to the line at y=2, and the gap below it isn't in the region.
2x=x2→x(x−2)=0→x=0,x=2
x=1:1≤y≤2
Turned about the x-axis, the far end traces a circle of radius 2 and the near end a circle of radius 1, and the empty gap leaves a hole. So the segment sweeps out a ring, the outer circle minus the hole.
π⋅22−π⋅12=4π−π=3π
The rectangle's height is 2−1=1, but squaring the height gives the wrong area: the farther an end is from the axis, the bigger the circle it traces.
π(2−1)2=π=3π
Give the ring thickness dx, and it becomes a washer. The outer radius R runs from the axis to the farther end, and the inner radius r to the nearer end.
Rotate the region between y=2x and y=x2 about the x-axis
Text solution
Add up the washersSquare each radius, subtract, and integrate from 0 to 2.
V=π∫02(4x2−x4)dx=π(332−532)=1564π
Check: a cone with its middle removedThe line alone sweeps a cone of radius 4 and height 2, and the parabola alone sweeps the solid we found with disks. Take one from the other.
π∫02(2x)2dx=332π
π∫02(x2)2dx=532π
332π−532π=1564π
For any region turned about the x-axis, each washer has an outer radius R and an inner radius r, both measured from the axis of rotation.
V=π∫ab(R2−r2)dx
2
Rotating about other horizontal lines
Let's take the same region between y=2x and y=x2, but rotate it about two new lines, first y=−1, below the region, and then y=5, above it.
y=−1:V=?y=5:V=?
y=−1:y=5:V=?V=?
Axis below the region
The radii are still distances from the axis to the ends of the rectangle. Since y=−1 sits 1 unit below the x-axis, each distance is 1 longer: from y=−1 up to a height h is h+1.
x=1:Rr=2+1=3=1+1=2
Rr=2x+1=x2+1
Axis above the region
With the axis at y=5, each distance runs down from the axis, so it's 5 minus the curve's height. At x=1 that's 3 to the line but 4 to the parabola, so this time the lower curve is the farther one.
x=1:Rr=5−1=4=5−2=3
Rr=5−x2=5−2x
Rotate the region between y=2x and y=x2 about y=−1, then about y=5
Text solution
About y=−1Expand both squares and subtract: the 1s cancel.
(2x+1)2−(x2+1)2=−x4+2x2+4x
V=π∫02(−x4+2x2+4x)dx=15104π
About y=5Now the parabola gives R. Expand and subtract: the 25s cancel.
(5−x2)2−(5−2x)2=x4−14x2+20x
V=π∫02(x4−14x2+20x)dx=15136π
A negative volume means a swapWith 5−2x as R, the same integral comes out negative, and a volume can't be.
π∫02[(5−2x)2−(5−x2)2]dx=−15136π
Does the upper curve always give the outer radius?
3
Rotating around vertical lines
Now let's rotate the same region around the y-axis, and then around the line x=3.
y-axis:V=?x=3:V=?
y-axis:x=3:V=?V=?
With a vertical axis, the rectangles lie across, at height y with thickness dy. So we write each curve as x in terms of y, and take the bounds in y.
y=2xy=x2(0,0),(2,4)→x=2y→x=y(x≥0)→0≤y≤4
Measured across from the y-axis, the parabola is the farther end, so it gives R. Around the x-axis, the line did.
y=1:Rr=1=21
Rr=y=2y
Moving the axis to x=3
The line x=3 is to the right of the region, so the rectangles still lie across, and each distance is now 3−x. At y=1, the line is 25 away and the parabola only 2, so this time the line gives R.
y=1:RR=3−21=25,=3−2y,rr=3−1=2=3−y
y=1:RrRr=3−21=25=3−1=2=3−2y=3−y
Rotate the region between y=2x and y=x2 around the y-axis, and around x=3
Text solution
Around the y-axisSquaring y gives just y, so the integrand is a polynomial.
V=π∫04(y−4y2)dy=π(8−316)=38π
Around x=3: square and subtractExpand both squares: the 9s cancel.
(3−2y)2−(3−y)2=4y2−4y+6y
IntegrateWrite 6y as 6y21, whose antiderivative is 4y23.
V=π[12y3−2y2+4y23]04=π(316−32+32)=316π
4
When the region has one curve
Rotating the region under y=x2 from x=0 to x=2 around the x-axis gave solid disks, with volume 532π, because the rectangles stood directly on the x-axis. Now let's rotate that same region around the y-axis.
y-axis:V=?
Around the y-axis the rectangles lie across. At height y=1, the rectangle runs from the curve at x=1 out to x=2, and nothing between it and the axis is in the region. So even with one curve, it sweeps out a washer, with R=2 out to the line and r=y in to the curve.
y≤x≤2:R=2,r=y
0≤y≤4
Find the volume when the region under y=x2 from x=0 to x=2 rotates around the y-axis
Text solution
Integrate in yThe outer radius is 2 at every height, and y runs from 0 up to 22=4.
V=π∫04(4−y)dy=π(16−8)=8π
Check: a cylinder with a bowl removedThe cylinder of radius 2 and height 4 holds 16π. Turning the region between the curve and the y-axis gives a bowl of 8π, and our solid is what's left.
π⋅22⋅4−8π=8π
When a rectangle reaches all the way to the axis of rotation, its nearer end is on the axis, so r=0. That turns the washer formula back into the disk formula.
r=0:π∫ab(R2−02)dx=π∫abR2dx
r=0:π∫ab(R2−02)dx=π∫abR2dx
Summary
The washer formula
Total volume
V=π∫ab(R2−r2)dx
Area of the ring at x=1
π(22−12)=3π
When a rectangle doesn't reach the axis of rotation, it sweeps out a washer with a hole in the middle. The outer radius R is the distance from the axis to the farther end of the rectangle, and the inner radius r is the distance to the nearer end. Square each radius separately before subtracting, so the area of the ring is π(R2−r2), never π(R−r)2.
Shifting a horizontal axis
Axis below the region
y=−1:Rr=2x+1=x2+1
Axis above the region
y=5:Rr=5−x2=5−2x
Measure both radii from the axis of rotation. When the axis is below the region at y=−1, add 1 to each height, so r=x2−(−1)=x2+1. When the axis is above the region at y=5, subtract each height from 5, so the distance down to y=2x is 5−2x.
Finding which curve gives R
y=5:x=3:R=5−x2R=3−2y
R is always the distance to the farther end of the rectangle. When the axis is above the region, the lower curve is farther away, so y=x2 gives R=5−x2. When a vertical axis is to the right of the region, the curve farther to the left is farther away, so x=2y gives R=3−2y. If the volume turns out negative, R and r were swapped.
Rotating about a vertical axis
Curves and bounds in y
x=2y,x=y,0≤y≤4
Total volume
V=π∫04[(y)2−(2y)2]dy
When the axis of rotation is vertical, use horizontal rectangles at height y with thickness dy. Solve each curve for x in terms of y, find the bounds in y, and measure each radius horizontally from the axis.
Holes and disks
Hole with one curve
y=x2,0≤x≤2y-axis:R=2,r=y
Reaching the axis
r=0:π∫abR2dx
A solid has a hole whenever the rectangle does not reach the axis of rotation, even if the region is bounded by only one curve. When a rectangle reaches the axis, the inner radius r is 0, and the washer formula becomes the disk formula.
5
Practice
Enter exact values in terms of π and e.
1
Find the volume of the solid formed when the region bounded by y=x and y=x2 is rotated about the x-axis.
At x=21, how far is each end of the rectangle from the x-axis?
If you got 30π Check the washer formula. Each end of the rectangle traces its own circle, so subtract the squares, π(R2−r2), rather than squaring the rectangle's height x−x2.
Find the boundsSet the two curves equal to find where they intersect.
x=x2→x(x−1)=0→x=0,x=1
Find the radiiAt x=21, the line is at y=21 and the parabola is at y=41, so the line is farther from the x-axis.
x=21:y=21,y=41→R=x,r=x2
IntegrateSubtract the inner area πr2 from the outer area πR2, then integrate from 0 to 1.
V=π∫01(x2−x4)dx=π[3x3−5x5]01=π(31−51)=152π
2
Find the volume of the solid formed when the region bounded by y=x2 and y=4 is rotated about the line y=4.
At x=1, the rectangle goes from y=1 to y=4. Is there any gap between it and the line y=4?
If you got 5256π Check the axis of rotation. We're rotating about the line y=4, not the x-axis, so measure the distances from y=4.
Find the radiusThe top of each rectangle lies directly on the axis of rotation y=4, so there's no hole, and the distance to the bottom edge is 4−x2.
x2≤y≤4:r=0,R=4−x2
IntegrateEach cross-section is a disk of radius 4−x2, so integrate π(4−x2)2 from −2 to 2.
Find the volume of the solid formed when the region bounded by y=x and y=x2 is rotated about the line y=2.
At x=41, the ends of the rectangle are at y=21 and y=161. Which end is farther from the line y=2?
If you got 103π Measure each radius from the axis y=2, not from the x-axis.If you got −3031π Check which curve gives the outer radius. The axis y=2 lies above the region, so the lower curve y=x2 is farther away and gives R.
Find the boundsSet x=x2 and square both sides to find where the curves intersect.
x=x2→x=x4→x(x3−1)=0→x=0,x=1
Find the radiiThe axis y=2 is above the whole region, so the lower curve y=x2 is farther from the axis than the upper curve y=x.
x=41:2−161=1631,2−21=23→R=2−x2,r=2−x
Subtract the squaresExpand R2 and r2, then subtract them.
(2−x2)2−(2−x)2=(4−4x2+x4)−(4−4x+x)=x4−4x2−x+4x
IntegrateIntegrate term by term from 0 to 1.
V=π∫01(x4−4x2−x+4x)dx=π(51−34−21+38)=3031π
4
Find the volume of the solid formed when the region bounded by y=x and y=x2 is rotated about the line x=−1.
The axis of rotation x=−1 is vertical, so we integrate with respect to y. How do you write y=x2 as x in terms of y?
How far is the curve x=y from the line x=−1?
If you got 6π The axis of rotation is x=−1, not the y-axis. Measure each radius from x=−1.If you got −6π Check how you measured the distance from x=−1. The distance from x=−1 to a point at x is x−(−1)=x+1, not x−1. That gives R=y+1 and r=y+1.If you got −2π Check which end is farther from x=−1. At y=41,y+1 is greater than y+1.
Rewrite the curves in terms of yThe axis of rotation is vertical, so slice with horizontal rectangles and solve each equation for x.
y=x→x=y,y=x2→x=y,0≤y≤1
Find the radiiThe axis x=−1 is to the left of the region, so add 1 to each x-coordinate to find the distance from the axis.
y=41:41+1=45,21+1=23→R=y+1,r=y+1
IntegrateExpand R2−r2, then integrate with respect to y from 0 to 1.
(y+1)2−(y+1)2=(y+2y+1)−(y2+2y+1)=2y−y−y2
V=π∫01(2y−y−y2)dy=π(34−21−31)=2π
5
Find the volume of the solid formed when the region in the first quadrant bounded by y=sinx,y=cosx and x=0 is rotated about the x-axis. (Challenge)
In the first quadrant, at what angle are sinx and cosx equal?
Which double-angle identity simplifies cos2x−sin2x?
If you got 4π2−2π Check the washer formula. We need R2−r2=cos2x−sin2x, not the squared height (cosx−sinx)2.
Find the boundsSet sinx=cosx to find where the two curves intersect in the first quadrant.
sinx=cosx→x=4π,0≤x≤4π
Find the radiiBetween 0 and 4π,cosx is greater than or equal to sinx, so cosx is farther from the x-axis.
0≤x≤4π:cosx≥sinx→R=cosx,r=sinx
Integrate using the double-angle identityReplace cos2x−sin2x with cos2x, then integrate from 0 to 4π.